Dana's file arrived at 12:04 a.m. the next morning, from an email address that looked like a cat had walked across a keyboard, and I read it in the office with the door shut and the rolltop lamp on and Ledger sitting on the printout like a paperweight with opinions.
Two hundred and eleven pages. The engagement letter. The scope of work. Six weeks of emails that I had somehow never seen, between Dana and a woman named Vivian Crewe-Lane, in a prose so polished it could have been framed. And at the very back, a spreadsheet Dana had attached without comment, titled CLIENT EXPENSES, JUNE-AUG.
I scrolled it with my chin on my fist.
Travel. Legal. A research retainer. And, down near the bottom, a line I read three times: Hale Investigative Services LLC, Dayton, OH. Field retainer, Ferris Gap matter. $18,500. Plus mileage.
I sat back.
"Tom Hale," I said to the cat. "Of a parking garage."
Ledger yawned.
By nine the next morning, I had made a plan. It was not a good plan, which was the best kind to have, since it left room for improvement.
"The idea," I told Marnie over the pancake griddle, "is to be so helpful that he can't get anything done."
"That's not an idea. That's my entire personality."
"Then you're perfect for it."
"I'll feed him," said Marnie, brightening with the grim joy of a woman who had been handed a weapon. "A man who's eaten my scrapple can't walk. It's a medical fact."
So it began. At eight, Tom Hale came down to a breakfast table set for twelve, for one, and was served, in order: a stack of buckwheat pancakes, a plate of scrapple, three eggs, a bowl of baked apples, a side of ham, a loaf of fresh brown bread with whipped butter, and a pot of coffee strong enough to sand a floor. Marnie hovered. She refilled. She asked if he was sure he wouldn't like a little more of anything. When he demurred, she looked wounded. When he took a second helping of the ham, her whole face shone with a terrible triumph.
"It's very kind," he said at nine, looking a little green.
"It's how we are," said Marnie.
At ten, I took him on the tour.
I want to say I gave it with a straight face. In truth I gave it with a Midwestern perkiness I'd perfected in hospitality seminars, and a deadpan so absolute that Odalys, trailing us with a feather duster, had to leave twice to laugh in a linen closet. I showed Hale the dining room. I explained the plaster ceiling roses, in detail, for nine minutes. I told him the history of the Larkspur's laundry chute, the 1951 Plumbing Controversy, the great Linen Strike of 1928 and every brand of soap used in the building since Calvin Coolidge.
"And on the third floor," I said, "we have the attic."
"I'm very interested in the second floor," said Hale.
"But there's so much to see on the third."
"I'd love to see Room Nine."
"It's occupied."
"I thought nobody had ever stayed in it."
"Spiritually," I said. "It's occupied spiritually. Now this, here, in the hall, this is our collection of antique doorknobs. There are forty-one."
He looked at the doorknobs. He looked at me. For one flicker, I saw it under the politeness, the narrowed, practiced calculation of a man who knew he was being handled and was deciding how much it would cost him to say so.
"They're lovely," he said, finally.
"I'm so glad you think so. Let's do the boiler."
We did the boiler. Gabe wasn't there. We did the cellar, the coal bin, the root cellar and Dot's collection of mason jars, which Hale photographed with a small, tight, practiced twitch of the wrist, and I watched his gaze slide to the back wall, to the hulking green mass of Gerald, to the dim corner behind him where a sawhorse and a coil of rope leaned against an old iron door.
"What's that?" he asked.
"A door," I said.
"To what?"
"A cellar."
"Isn't this a cellar?"
"It's a cellar for the cellar." I turned. "Would you like to see the pantry? We have three hundred pounds of flour."
He did not want to see the pantry.
By the second night, Hale had taken, by my count, two hundred and eighteen photographs, asked eleven pointed questions about Room Nine and been told eleven things that were not quite lies. He'd been given directions to the library, which was closed. He'd been recommended a trail that did not exist. He had spent forty minutes in the dining room listening to Iggy Sobel explain the history of the band program in what was supposed to be a casual conversation about "the old days," and had emerged looking like a man who'd been physically stroked by a very large glove.
On the second afternoon I found Gabe on the new stair with a level and a mouthful of nails, and I told him everything I'd learned from Dana's file. Everything except the part with my name on it. I said Hale was working for a company called Crewe Hospitality. I said they had an offer on the Larkspur sitting on Lowell's desk. I said I had a source, and I didn't say who, and he didn't ask.
"Crewe," he said, around the nails. He took them out, one at a time. "As in Harlan Crewe. As in the Cadillac."
"His daughter runs it."
"Of course she does." He set the level on the rail and stared out across the yard at the sagging gray roof of the depot, a quarter mile away, where a thread of smoke had not risen in nine nights. "She's been waiting forty years to buy the thing that ruined her family's name."
"Or the thing that proves it."
"Is that what you think?"
"I don't know what I think," I said. "I know a man who photographs old wood is sleeping next to Room Nine, and that I put him there myself."
"On purpose?"
"It's called keeping your enemies where you can hear them breathe."
He almost smiled. "Dot used to say that."
"Dot used to say a lot of things." I thought of the letter in my back pocket, and I almost said it then, I had my mouth open, and Gabe looked at me with those clear lake eyes, and the sun came out from behind a cloud and put a gold bar across his forearm.
"The inspection's tomorrow," I said instead.
"I'll be done by midnight."
"Gabe."
"Don't." He picked the level up again. "I know what you were going to say. Say it after the stair. I can't hold two things."
So I let it go, again, and I knew exactly what I was doing, and I hated myself with a tidy and professional thoroughness.
On the third evening, the Liars got him.
I didn't plan it. It happened the way these things do in Ferris Gap, which is to say that at seven o'clock Hale wandered into the lobby with a notebook, seeking a quiet corner, and found only one empty chair, at the card table, between Ray Novak and Wick Tolliver.
"Sit," said Wick.
"Oh, I wouldn't want to impose."
"Nobody's imposing. We need a fourth. Do you play?"
"A little."
"Excellent," said Iggy, dealing. "We'll teach you."
An hour later, I stood behind the desk with a stack of invoices I was not reading and watched Tom Hale lose forty-one dollars at cribbage to three old men who had designed, over fifty years, a collective strategy for taking tourists' money so gently that the tourists thanked them. He was good. Cleverly bad, I thought. A man who lost on purpose and watched their hands. But the Liars didn't just play cribbage. They talked.
"And that," Iggy was saying, "is why you should never trust a man who says he's a photographer."
"Why not?" said Hale.
"Because they never take pictures of people. Only of things. Locks, hinges, old books. Ever notice that?"
"Can't say I have."
"Wick, tell him about the Ferris Gap Ghost."
"There is no Ferris Gap Ghost." Wick laid a card. "There was a woman, once, who liked to walk at night. Thin. Gray cardigan. Little round glasses. She'd come into the lobby at three in the morning and sit by the fire. Dot would find her there and bring her a cup of tea. She never spoke."
My pen stopped.
"When was this?" Hale said, too lightly.
"Oh, years back. Before your time." Wick didn't look up. "Fifteen for two. She's gone now. Nobody knows where. Some people say she's still around. I say that's what the dead do. They walk."
"Interesting."
"Isn't it?" Wick's peg moved across the board, two holes, three. "You keep your eyes open on the stair, Mr. Hale. It's an old building. You never know who you'll meet."
Ray said nothing. Ray, who had not said a word to me in a week but "pass the butter," took a long slow sip of coffee and looked at Hale over the rim of the cup for a very long time. It was the look of a man who has put out fires for twenty-six years and knows precisely what a match smells like.
"Mr. Hale," he said. "What do you do for a living?"
"I'm in consulting."
"Ah." Ray put down his cup. "Then you and Nell have a lot in common."
I had never loved a man more than I did at that moment.
Hale left the table at nine. He climbed the stairs with his notebook, with a small, tired, gracious smile. At the turn of the stair I watched his shoulders drop an inch, the way a man's do when he thinks the room is no longer looking, and then straighten.
It was an hour before I followed.
The notebook was lying on the hall radiator outside Room Eight, as if he'd set it down to look for his key and forgotten it, which I did not believe for a second. Ledger was lying on it. I stood for a long moment and looked at the cat, and the cat looked at me, and then, with a certain regal slowness, he stood, stretched and walked away, leaving the book open.
I didn't touch it. I read it where it lay.
A list. Dates. Room 9 / 4th panel, W side? / verify w/ L.P. Ledger (registry) 10/19/83 photographed. Hartigan, N.: avoids R9, consults carpenter G.N., has letter?? Depot: occupied, female, ~65, mobility L hip. Tunnel confirmed? Tell V.: she's here.
Tell V.
I stood in the dim hallway of my aunt's inn, with the lights flickering and a cat winding between my ankles, and the back of my neck went cold.
And then, because the universe likes a cheap trick, a small noise came from the end of the hall. A very small one. A tiny, metallic scratch. I turned.
The door of Room Nine had a brass plate around the lock. The plate was bright and unmarred. But there, on the polished surface, new as a fresh wound, ran three fine, silvery scratches, in a neat parallel row.
Somebody had tried to pick it.
And the lock, a hundred-and-thirty-year-old mortise, with a brass key I had hung back on its hook, did not care. It had held for forty-two years. But from the shadows of the hall behind me, soft as a page turning, came the click of the door of Room Eight.
Opening.

