Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 5

Born Dale Kimmel

The records window for name changes is in the basement of the civil wing, behind a door that sticks and a counter where a clerk named Delroy has been waiting for someone to ask him an interesting question since before the building had working elevators.

“Fisk,” he said. “Leonard Fisk.” He typed with two fingers and a lot of conviction. “Petition for change of name. Granted. Eight years ago this September.”

“Can I see the petition?”

“You can see it for a dollar a page.” He glanced at Bernie, who had arrived, as usual, a half-second behind me and holding something to eat. “No food in the records room.”

“It’s a pretzel,” Bernie said. “It’s practically a document.”

He printed the pages. Two of them. The petition was the form kind, filled in on a typewriter with the careless rigor of someone who’d rather not be noticed. Petitioner: Dale Kimmel. Proposed name: Leonard Fisk. Reason for request: “Petitioner wishes to leave behind a name associated with public notoriety.” No objection filed. Order signed in under ten days.

I read it standing at the counter. I read the name at the top once and felt the floor shift an inch, the way it does just before a verdict.

“Bernie.”

“Mm.”

“Kimmel.”

“Rings something,” she said, chewing. “Hold on.” She stopped chewing. “The fire.”

I had been twenty-one when it happened. I was in my last year of college in Philadelphia, studying for the exams that would get me into law school, and what I remembered most was not the fire itself. It was the cross-examination, which I’d read two years later in a trial advocacy seminar, in a photocopied transcript with the margins gone gray from a hundred students’ pencils.

Commonwealth v. Kimmel. A warehouse. A fire marshal with a theory about pour patterns. And a defense lawyer who cross-examined that fire marshal for four hours, one patient question at a time, until the jury could see the theory had no floor under it.

That lawyer was the best trial lawyer in the city. He’d tried the case personally, though he was Chief of Homicide Defense and had no reason to. We’d all been taught it as a miracle.

“Kimmel’s the guy Pike got off,” Bernie said slowly. “The Kasparian warehouse. Wasn’t that...”

I was already at the other window, asking for the docket. It took Delroy twelve minutes and a lot of sighing, and when it came it was thinner than I’d imagined, a few pages of caption and counsel. The Commonwealth versus Dale Edward Kimmel. Charges: arson endangering persons, risking catastrophe, murder of the second degree. Defense counsel of record: Arden M. Pike, Esq., Chief, Homicide Defense.

My mentor had been Leonard Fisk’s lawyer.

“Keep reading,” Bernie said, very gently, which is how I knew she’d already seen it.

I looked at the next line. The victim. The man who’d died when a warehouse full of rugs went up in the middle of the night, sleeping in the back office because he’d had a fight with his father and hadn’t wanted to go home.

Aram Vahan Kasparian, age 24.

We took the docket to a diner on Arch Street, because I couldn’t be in that basement anymore. Bernie ordered pancakes and I ordered a coffee I didn’t drink, and we spread the pages across the table between the ketchup and the napkins.

“The Commonwealth’s report calls him Fisk,” Bernie said. “Brackett’s affidavit calls him Fisk. The DA’s discovery says, and I’m quoting, ‘motive undetermined.’ They don’t know. Nobody on the other side has put this together.”

“Levon knew.”

“Levon sat in your interview room and told you the dead man was nobody.”

“He told me the reason was a person,” I said. “A person who was dead. I thought he meant...” I put my hand over my mouth for a second. “He meant his brother. He went to that house to kill the man who killed his brother. And he told me, without telling me anything, because he wouldn’t put Aram’s name in the air.”

“Your client’s a romantic.”

“My client,” I said, “just handed the Commonwealth the best motive in the history of murder, and he isn’t aware they haven’t found it.”

“Not yet.”

“Not yet.”

Bernie reached into her tote and set a folded newspaper clipping on top of the docket. She said she’d found it in the library archive that morning. She pushed it toward me without looking up. A young man in a black suit stood at the edge of a grave with his hand on a casket.

The caption gave his name. “Levon Kasparian, 23, brother of the victim.” He hadn’t had the lines around his mouth yet. He was crying the way men cry when they’ve been told it isn’t allowed, which is to say not at all, and everything in his face was working very hard.

I looked at that photograph for longer than I’ll admit to anyone.

“Here’s the thing, kid,” Bernie said. “You see the knot, right? Pike lied at the preliminary hearing. ‘Did you know the occupant?’ ‘No.’ Under oath. He represented the man. He had to know the man’s face.”

“Yes.”

“So you’ve got him. Perjury, a sworn lie, in front of a judge. You can burn him to the ground.”

“And the second I stand up and ask him about Kimmel in front of a jury...”

“They learn who Kimmel was,” Bernie said. “And whose brother he burned, whatever a jury said about it.” She pushed a piece of pancake around. “You can’t impeach him without handing them the motive. And you can’t win without impeaching him.”

“Somebody built this,” I said.

“Somebody built what?”

“A witness I can’t touch.” I held the docket up like a mirror. “Whoever put Arden on that sidewalk knew exactly what happens when I cross him.”

Bernie didn’t answer. She was a cop for twenty-two years and she had the grace to know when a theory deserved to be left alone for a few minutes.

I walked home that night through Queen Village, the long way, past the shuttered shops and the water-ice stand with its windows taped over for the winter. My apartment is one bedroom and a closet. In the closet is a second filing cabinet that I don’t open, and I stood in front of it for a moment before I walked past, because there are cases I keep and cases I count, and I’d made a habit of knowing which was which.

My phone had a voicemail from my mother, four minutes and eleven seconds long. I played it on speaker while I took off my shoes.

“Priya, it’s Mummy. I’m only calling to say your father says he saw your name in the newspaper. He said nothing, but he read it twice. You know how he is. He folded it into the drawer with the electric bills. That is his highest honor.” A pause, a rustle, the sound of her pulling a chair out. “Are you eating? That family in the newspaper. They say they are, you know. Dangerous. Be careful. And Mrs. Venkataraghavan’s son still has no girlfriend.”

I counted it, and for once I didn’t have a column for it.

I spread the old transcript across the kitchen table. I’d photocopied Arden’s cross of the fire marshal that afternoon.

I read it again the way you read a letter from someone who’s no longer who they were. Question, answer, question, answer, patient as water. “Mr. Marshal, you’ve said the accelerant was poured in a trail. Would you describe the trail?” I could hear the cadence of it. I could hear him in my own voice, the way I asked a question and let the silence do the rest.

I turned back to the docket. The caption, the counsel, the victim, the verdict. A jury had spent four hours deciding that Dale Kimmel hadn’t killed Aram Kasparian. Three years after the verdict, Dale Kimmel had become Leonard Fisk. Eleven years after it, Leonard Fisk was dead.

Leonard Fisk had been my mentor’s greatest acquittal. And my client’s brother had died in his fire.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!