Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 21

Bread Box

Levon drove. I called Cole Whitaker from the passenger seat before we cleared the city line, because for the first time in my career I had a piece of evidence I was not allowed to touch and a witness who might not wait.

"Do not open it," Cole said. "Do not let her open it. Do not stand in her kitchen and become a chain-of-custody problem. Okafor will meet you there."

"When?"

"He's in Bethlehem on a burglary. Ninety minutes." A pause, and the double click of the pen. "Priya. You're on leave. You are not her lawyer. You're not anybody's lawyer today."

"I'm aware."

"You're doing the face. I can hear it."

I hung up. Levon kept his eyes on the turnpike. "He can hear your face?"

"He lost to it in moot court for three years."

Joanne Pruitt lived on a street of brick twins near an old silk mill, each with an aluminum awning and a cement stoop swept clean. She was fifty-two, small and square, with reading glasses pushed into gray-blonde hair and the careful voice of a woman who runs a school cafeteria and has learned to say hard things in a tone that makes nobody cry. She opened the door before we knocked.

"You're taller than on the news," she said to Levon. Then, to me: "You said his name. You said Dale Kimmel in front of a whole courtroom and nobody threw anything."

"One person coughed," I said.

"That's more than he got in forty-nine years."

Across the street, a gray sedan sat at the curb with a man behind the wheel. I wrote the plate on my hand, the way Bernie taught me, because a legal pad is a thing you can lose and a hand is not. The man was perhaps forty, bored, with a coffee cup on the dash. He watched the mailbox of number 38 and nothing else.

"Is he family?" I asked Levon, low.

Levon looked for a long moment. "Family doesn't rent. That's a rental." He started toward the door. "I'm going to ask him what he's waiting for."

"You're going to stand in the kitchen and let a detective ask."

"Respectfully," he said, and stayed.

The kitchen smelled of onions and floor soap. On the counter, beside a rooster-shaped cookie jar, sat a steel bread box with a dent in the lid. Joanne put both hands flat on the counter and didn't touch it.

"It's been there since the eleventh of October. I put my bread on top of it. Ray thought I'd lost my mind." She pushed up her glasses. "I knew it was something from him. I knew if I opened it, he'd really be dead."

I told her what Cole had said. I told her that a detective was on his way, that the package might matter in a courtroom, and that nothing in it was a thing she had to do before she was ready. I did not tell her what I believed, which was that a dead man had mailed his last words to the one person who loved him and then asked her to give them to a stranger.

Okafor arrived at 3:40, with a camera, a box of gloves, and the patient manner of a man who has been told things by frightened people his whole career. Out the front window I watched the gray sedan pull from the curb the moment his car turned onto the street. It went unhurried, signal blinking, a man leaving a parking spot for an ordinary reason.

"Plate," Okafor said.

I held up my hand. He looked at it, and then at me, and wrote it down without a word.

He opened the bread box himself, on video, narrating the date and time and the names of everyone in the room. Inside was a padded mailer with a handwritten address in block capitals. JOANNE PRUITT. Postmarked Roxborough, October ninth. Joanne said, "That's his printing. He printed everything. He said his handwriting looked like a ransom note."

Okafor slid out four items and set them on a clean paper towel, one by one.

A card, in the same block capitals: GIVE THIS TO THE FIRST PERSON WHO SAYS MY REAL NAME OUT LOUD IN A COURTROOM. A small sealed envelope marked JO-JO. A thick sealed envelope marked LEVON KASPARIAN. HAND TO HIM BEFORE THE POLICE. THEN GIVE THE POLICE EVERYTHING. And a brass key on a green plastic tag, stamped 2218, with a bank's folded receipt wrapped around it: Wissahickon Savings and Trust, Manayunk branch, safe deposit rental, paid through next October in the name of Leonard Fisk.

"I can't give him that one first," Okafor said, quietly, to me. "It's evidence. It was found in a homicide victim's mail. I'd need to read it, photograph it, log it."

"He asked for Mr. Kasparian before you," I said.

"He asked for a lot of things. He's dead."

I looked at Joanne. She looked at the thick envelope, and at the tall man standing by her refrigerator with his hands carefully open at his sides.

"Detective," I said, "who owns that envelope?"

"The addressee."

"It was mailed to Mrs. Pruitt. It was delivered to Mrs. Pruitt. It's hers until she hands it to someone. You can photograph the front and back, and the seal, in this kitchen, on video, before anything else happens. Then she gives it to the man it's addressed to, and he opens it at this table with you standing three feet away, and you copy every page the minute he's done." I took a breath. "That's not a violation of anything. It's a woman handing her brother's mail to the man her brother wrote to. I'd like to see anyone try to suppress that."

Okafor thought about it for three full seconds, which for a detective is an act of generosity.

"That's either brilliant," he said, "or a motion in six months."

"It could be both."

"Mrs. Pruitt? Is that what you want?"

"It's what he wanted," Joanne said.

He photographed the envelope front and back, the flap, the tape, the pencil dent where Dale had pressed too hard on the L. He nodded. Joanne picked it up in both hands the way you pick up a casserole that is still hot, and carried it across the kitchen, and gave it to Levon.

"He wrote your name three times," she said. "I think he practiced."

Levon sat. He looked at the envelope, and I watched him square it to the edge of the table, very slowly, with the side of his thumb. Then he looked at what he'd done and let his hand fall away, and left it crooked.

He opened it with a butter knife from Joanne's drawer. Eight pages, handwritten on lined yellow paper, both sides, in the blocky printing of a man who was afraid his handwriting would give him away.

Okafor's camera light was a small red dot. The refrigerator hummed. Across the street, the space at the curb stayed empty.

Levon read the first line to himself. Then he read it again, out loud, in the level voice I had first heard in a jail attorney room, a voice with no theater in it, because he did not know any other way to say a thing like this.

"'Mr. Kasparian. I set the fire that killed your brother. I put that first so that everything after it will be easier to believe.'"

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!