Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 18

The Second Door

I drove from Cherry Hill to Center City in nineteen minutes, which I’d like noted as the only time in my life I have exceeded a speed limit for a man I wanted to strangle.

I called his phone eleven times. It was off. I called Levon, who answered on the first ring in a voice that said he hadn’t slept, and asked whether Hrant’s people had anything on the Northeast side that morning, because a seventy-one-year-old jurist with a tremor had a ten-minute head start and a plan he called managing. Levon said he was already in the car. I said, “Wait.” He said, “I’ve been waiting since Sunday.” The line went to road noise.

Then, at 7:58, my phone rang with a number I’d been avoiding for a week. COLE WHITAKER, ADA, said the screen, the way it had since law school.

“Priya,” said Cole. He sounded like a man trying to buy a coffee with a hundred-dollar bill. “I have a retired Common Pleas judge in my conference room. He walked in at ten minutes to eight, past the metal detector, and told the deputy he wished to make a statement without delay. He says you’ll want to be here. He also says, and I’m quoting, that he’s very sorry about the hour.”

I pulled into a bus lane on Market Street, put my forehead on the steering wheel, and laughed until a man in a transit vest tapped on my window.

The conference room was on the ninth floor of the District Attorney’s Office, a sealed rectangle with a long table, bad coffee, and a view of an air shaft. Arden Pike sat at the center of it as he’d sit at the head of a bench, in his gray suit and a bow tie the color of a ripe plum, with the manila envelope placed squarely in front of him and both hands on the table. The right one shook. He had not hidden it.

Beside him, in a damp raincoat, with the expression of a man who has been dragged to the front of a bus, sat Michael Dolan.

“Dolan,” I said.

“Priya.” He looked at me with the terror of a lawyer who has lost four trials and been asked to represent a legend. “Judge Pike called me from the lobby. He asked for the worst trial lawyer in the Defender’s Office. He said he didn’t deserve a good one.”

“I said,” Arden corrected, “that I didn’t deserve a flattering one. It’s not the same.”

Cole stood at the window with his back to the room. He turned when I came in. He looked, for a man who’d spent a week watching his case fall in on itself, entirely himself: rumpled, forgettable, honest, a face you wouldn’t recognize in a crowd and wouldn’t forget in a courtroom. He clicked his pen twice.

“I told him to wait for you, and he declined. I told him to wait for counsel, and he called Dolan.” He glanced at the old man. “He’s been talking for fifty minutes. A detective from the Special Investigations Unit has the first draft. It isn’t Brackett.”

“I thought you’d want that noted,” said Arden.

“I did. Thank you.” Cole turned the chair opposite him around and sat, backwards, which he’d done at moot court at twenty-four and which I’d found irritating then. “Priya, I’m going to be straight, because I’m told you prefer it, and because you’re about to be a witness to what’s in that envelope, not his lawyer. You’ll sit there and not say a word. Understood?”

“For the record,” I said, “I’d have said it in the car.”

“I know.” He almost smiled. “You still owe me a rematch for the finals, by the way.”

“I’ll file the motion.”

He turned to the envelope. “Judge Pike has laid out a story that explains everything I couldn’t explain for two months. It puts a man named Vartan Boghosian in that side passage at 11:23. It says a telephone call at 8:31 put him there. It says why the Commonwealth’s best eyewitness told a Municipal Court judge something that wasn’t so.” His voice was very even. “I believe him. I believe every page. And I’m going to explain to you why that’s the worst news I’ve had all year.”

“Mr. Whitaker,” said Dolan faintly.

“Hear me out, Counsel. Your client has lied under oath twice. He has taken money from a criminal organization for eleven years, a fact he’s volunteered, and I admire it, and it will end him on cross-examination. Any defense lawyer in the city, and there are several I’d hire, will stand up in front of a jury and ask whether a man who’s been owned for eleven years has ever told the truth for free. Your client is a cooked witness.” He looked at Arden, with a kind of sorrow. “I mean that with respect, Judge.”

“It is an accurate description,” said Arden.

“Second. The 8:04 call. Mr. Kimmel was your client in the fire case. Dead clients have privilege. A court will have to decide whether what he said to you that night is protected, or whether the crime-fraud exception reaches it. Probably it does. That’s a briefing schedule and a hearing, and it’s weeks.” Click, click. “Third. This phone.” He tapped the stapled sheet. “Two lines highlighted. The incoming from 8:04 is Leonard Fisk’s cell, and I can confirm that, because I’ve known his number since the second day. The outgoing at 8:31 goes to a number ending in 5502 which is a prepaid phone with no subscriber. Whoever bought it paid cash at a pharmacy chain in the Northeast and never gave a name. I can tell a jury a man dialed it. I can’t tell them who answered, except through the one witness whose credibility we’ve just discussed.”

“So you can’t use it,” I said, which I’d promised not to say.

“I can use it,” said Cole Whitaker, quietly. “I just can’t win with it. That’s a different problem, and it’s the one I’d like help with.”

The room was very still. Somewhere in the walls, a radiator knocked.

“Mr. Whitaker,” said Arden Pike. “I have been a judge and a defender and a witness, and I have discovered in the last two months that I am a poor example of all three. I’m not here to be believed. I came to be useful. If you can find a way to use a cooked witness, I’m available to be eaten.”

“That’s very generous,” Cole said, “and slightly horrifying.”

“I thought it should be both.”

Dolan, in his raincoat, made a small noise that I recognized as the first sound of a man beginning to enjoy himself.

I should have felt triumph. What I felt was a cold, clear fear for a man in a plum bow tie who’d spent three nights in my parents’ house and then walked into a building to hand himself in. I did not want him eaten. I wanted to take him back to Cherry Hill and have my mother make him eat a second bowl of rice.

“Why this morning?” I said. “You said Wednesday.”

He turned to me. Even sitting, even shaking, he was somehow the tallest man in the room.

“Because your mother gave me dinner last night,” Arden said, “and I found that I could not eat another one as a man with this in his pocket.”

I looked at the table. Nobody else said anything.

Cole’s phone, on the glass, lit up. He glanced at it, and then at me, and there was something in his face I hadn’t seen before. Not triumph either. The look of a man who has been holding a door shut with his shoulder and has just felt it give.

“Brackett’s lawyer called me at six this morning,” he said. “He’s an excellent lawyer, and expensive, and a day ago he told me his client wouldn’t speak to anyone. This morning, he asked what time I could see him.” He picked up the phone. “Brackett doesn’t want to talk about the video. He wants to talk about what else he cut. He says it wasn’t only the video.”

“What else was there?”

“A phone,” said Cole.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!