Arden Pike has never in his life left a door open.
He closes them the way other men sign contracts, with attention, so that nothing needs to be said afterward. So when Bernie’s car pulled up on his street in Mount Airy at 8:30 that Saturday night and I saw the front door of the stone twin standing open by exactly the width of my hand, I knew the number before I counted it.
A hand’s width. The same gap. The same black line down the edge of a house.
“Don’t,” said Bernie, because I had already started up the walk. “Priya. Stop. Take the phone out of your pocket.”
I stopped. I took the phone out of my pocket. On the sidewalk of a street where a retired judge’s lamps were lit and his station wagon sat in the driveway with its dented bumper, I did the thing a man had once told me he had never been taught.
I called it in.
“This is Priya Raman,” I told the dispatcher. “I’m an attorney. I’m at the home of a seventy-one-year-old man who isn’t answering his telephone. His front door is open and his lights are on. I’d like a welfare check, please, and I’m going to stay on the line.” I gave the address. I understood why Levon had never called from the sidewalk of a dead man’s house. It is an unnatural thing. It felt like signing a document I had not read.
“Units are six minutes out,” the dispatcher said. “Ma’am, do not enter the premises.”
“Of course,” I said, and walked in.
Bernie came behind me, one hand inside her tote, where I suspect she keeps nothing more lethal than a pretzel and a bad temper.
The house was warm and smelled of old books and wool. The hall light was on. The drawers in the console table were shut too neatly, each one flush, the way a thing is shut by someone who wants you to think it was never open. In the living room, the books had been reshelved by somebody who didn’t read: the Pennsylvania Reports upside down between a biography and a volume of Trollope.
Habeas came out of the kitchen with his ears down and leaned his whole warm weight against my shins.
“Arden?” I said.
He was in the dining room, in Eleanor’s chair. His coat was on, buttoned to the collar, and a dish towel lay across his lap with his right hand hidden under it. The chair at the head of the table was pushed in. The tea tray was set for one.
“Priya,” said Arden Pike. He didn’t stand. “You’re very prompt. I’d have been alarmed if you weren’t.”
“You didn’t answer your phone.”
“I turned it off.” He nodded at the dish towel. “On Thursday. It was the only thing in this house that was still mine to refuse.”
Sirens, then, at the end of the street. Bernie went to the door and talked to someone in the voice she’d used for twenty-two years. Two officers came in as far as the hall, a young one and an older sergeant who took one look at the man in the dining room and straightened as if the bench had been brought in with him.
“Judge Pike. Sir. We had a call.”
“Which I regret, Sergeant, and which was entirely correct. I’m a retired jurist and I’m quite alive. I have been tidying, and I left the door open, and I’m informed that’s a dangerous thing to do.” His voice was the voice I remembered, dry and measured. “Would you do an old man the kindness of going home?”
They went. Policemen do what Arden asks. It has gotten a great many men into trouble.
When the door closed, the house made no sound at all.
“They were very polite,” Arden said.
“Who?”
“Mr. Kasparian came on Thursday for tea. Vartan took off his cap at the door.” He moved the dish towel a quarter inch. “Vartan examined the house while I made it. He did the library, the desk, Eleanor’s closet. I gave him the run of it. They did not find what they were after because I’d given it to you in the corridor, and Hrant knows that I did. He was very gentle. He asked me to retrieve it. He said I was an old friend and it would be a mercy.” The tremor made the towel shiver. “I said I would think. I have been thinking in this chair for two days, and I haven’t been able to find the end of it.”
“Arden.” “You told me to open it if you stopped answering.”
“Yes.”
“You stopped answering.”
“I’d like you to open it here,” he said, “so I have to watch. I can’t do it in my own voice. I’ve been trying.”
Bernie took the chair by the door. I sat across from him and drew out the manila envelope that had ridden in my tote for ten days and was not even creased.
Inside were seven sheets of yellow legal paper in his small upright hand, a stapled phone statement with two lines highlighted in orange, and a single card with the Defender’s Office seal that said, in his writing, Priya, you were right not to ask.
I read the first page twice. The heading said:
Statement of Arden M. Pike, made without counsel, Saturday, October 11, 3:10 a.m. To be opened if I cease to answer my telephone.
At 8:04 p.m. on Friday, October 10, my telephone rang. The caller gave his name as Dale Kimmel. I had not heard that voice in eleven years. He told me he had been dying since June. He said he had a thing to say about the fire, that he had said it to no one, and that he wished to say it to me, because I had once saved his life and he thought I owed him the hearing. He asked me to come to his house at half past eleven. The front door would be unlatched. He said he’d be waiting up.
At 8:31 I did what I had sworn in this house I would never do again. I telephoned a number I have known by heart for eleven years. It is the number I was given on the first Tuesday after Kimmel walked. I told the man who answered that Dale was alive and had decided to talk.
I told myself I was giving him warning. I told myself I was giving him the chance to decide, as a gentleman would. I thought of Eleanor’s chemotherapy and my house and my name. The man said, “Thank you, Arden. Go home and have your dinner.”
I did not go home. I drove to Ferncliff Street. I parked at the corner and sat in the car for fifty minutes, because I had done what I had done and I could not get out and walk to a door and look at a man I’d sold.
At 11:31 a man in a flat cap bent to my window. I have known him for eleven years. He is Vartan Boghosian, and he has brought me an envelope on the first Tuesday of every month for as long as I’ve been owned. He said, very kindly, “Judge, he’s already gone. It was not meant to be like this. There will be a young man at the door shortly, and a policeman will be along in the morning. You may be a witness, or you may be a suspect. You have until you start the car.”
He tapped the roof of my car twice. I said nothing. That was my answer.
I put the pages down. I had been holding my breath for the length of a closing argument.
“The phone,” Arden said, from a very long way off. He nodded at the stapled sheet. “The eight thirty-one call, the second line. Five-five-oh-two. It’s not in my directory. I’ve never had to look it up.”
“Arden.”
“You asked me on the stand whether I had ever met Leonard Fisk. I said no. You did not ask who I called. If you had asked that first, I would have told you everything, and Levon Kasparian would have been home in a week, and there would be no envelope.” He lifted his right hand out from under the towel at last and let me look at it, shaking. “I want you to read the last page aloud.”
I turned it over. It was one paragraph.
I did not kill Leonard Fisk. I have been very careful to say so, to myself and to anyone who asked. But I wish it entered somewhere in a record that I called Hrant Kasparian at 8:31 and told him Dale was going to talk.
“Priya,” said the man who had taught me to try a case. “I killed Leonard Fisk with a telephone.”

