Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 13

Complaint

They boxed my office by eleven on Monday morning.

I want it noted that nobody was cruel about it. A paralegal named Dev brought the flattened cardboard up from the supply room and apologized to each box individually. Somebody from facilities offered me a bag of the good tape. Renata Sobel stood in the doorway of my cubicle holding her chipped tea mug, saying nothing, which for her is a eulogy.

“Paid administrative leave,” she said at last. “Pending the Board’s inquiry. The First Assistant wanted unpaid. I wanted a sandwich. We compromised on paid.”

“Renata, the complaint is weak.”

“It’s weak on the law. It’s heavy on the photograph.” She came in and sat on the edge of my desk, which she has never done in seven years. “Rule 1.8(j). A lawyer shall not have sexual relations with a client unless the relationship predates the representation. You withdrew Friday. You kissed him Friday. A reasonable person looks at that photograph and sees an ending. Mr. Sachs would like the Board to see a beginning.”

She slid her phone across the blotter. The complaint was eight pages, mostly adjectives, signed by a man who had once represented my client’s family and now apparently represented my client’s family’s feelings. At paragraph six it quoted a conversation word for word.

Ms. Raman: “Technically you’re my client until I file the withdrawal.” Mr. Kasparian: “Then I’d like you to file it.”

I looked up. “That was the steps. Wednesday evening. Nobody was within thirty feet.”

“Somebody was within thirty feet and a very good memory.” Renata turned her mug a quarter turn. “Somebody who also had a camera on Friday. It reads like a transcript by a man who was taking his time.”

“Vart.”

“I don’t know the name and I don’t want it in this office.” She took her phone back. “Priya. Listen to me, because I’m going to say it once and then go back to being a woman of few words. The Board isn’t going to suspend you for kissing a man the day after you left his case. They’ll take it seriously, and they’ll have you in a room for months. That’s what this is for. Someone wants you in a room, answering questions, for a long time. Do you understand what they are going to ask you in that room?”

“Everything.”

“Self-report,” Renata said. “Everything. Everything the complaint doesn’t know. If you tell it first, it isn’t leverage. It’s just a bad day.”

I held my coffee in both hands, as if it were a small animal. “I’ve never lost a jury trial.”

“You’ve never lost a jury trial,” Renata said, “and I’d like to know how many things you’ve avoided so you could say that sentence.”

She went back to her office. I put my legal pad in the first box, then took it out again, because I wasn’t ready to stop knowing things.

That afternoon, in my apartment, I did the only thing I know to do when the room goes sideways. I drew three columns. KNOWN, PROVABLE, HOPED.

Under KNOWN, I wrote Hrant Kasparian sent a box of gata and a docket. Under PROVABLE I wrote nothing for a while. Under HOPED I wrote nothing at all. It was a clean page, and I hated it, the way I’d hated that first page in the jail.

Then I did a thing I hadn’t done in three years. I took the cap off a pen and wrote, at the top of a new sheet, in my regular handwriting, the words TERRENCE MABRY.

Under KNOWN: Armed robbery with injury. Plea. Twelve to twenty-four. Sentenced three years ago. A witness I never chased.

Under PROVABLE: A witness I never chased.

Under HOPED, I sat there until my coffee went cold. Then I wrote one word: forgiveness. And crossed it out. That wasn’t mine to hope for.

My phone buzzed on the counter. A voicemail, my mother’s. I listened to it standing up, which is the only polite way.

“Priya, it’s Mummy. I’m sorry to bother you, I know you are very busy with the television. Mrs. Venkataraghavan’s niece says she saw you on the news with a man in a long coat. I told her it must be a client. Is it a client? Your father says not to ask, and I am not asking, I am merely wondering in a loud voice. Also the dentist boy’s mother is making a lemon pickle. Call me. Please also eat.”

I counted it as one. Then I counted it as the first one I’d been grateful for in a month.

Bernie arrived at seven with a soft pretzel in a paper bag and a banker’s box that was not mine. She dropped it on my kitchen table and sat, back to the wall, eyes on the door.

“Here’s the thing, kid. I’m on vacation. I put in for it at noon. I’m told I have eleven days I’ve never used.” She tore the pretzel in half. “This is the file on Terrence Mabry. I pulled it from archives myself, which I’m not supposed to do, and I read it on the train. You want to know what I found?”

“No.”

“Yes you do.” She pushed the bigger half toward me. “There’s a woman. Dorothea Banks. Home health aide, works nights. She gave a statement to the first responding officer, three lines, saying she saw two men run from the corner store that night and neither one was a tall man in a gray hoodie. Mabry’s a tall man in a gray hoodie. The statement was in the discovery. Nobody followed up. Not the police. Not the prosecutor.” She looked at me over her pretzel. “Not the defense.”

“It was in the discovery.”

“It was in the discovery, on page forty-one, in a stack of three hundred. I know because I turned to it in about eleven seconds, and I wasn’t looking hard.” Bernie wiped her fingers. “I’m not saying it to hurt you. I’m saying you can’t unknow it, and the Board’s going to want to ask whether you did.”

“I did know it,” I said. “I knew it after the plea. I read page forty-one in the car, in the parking lot, after he’d been sentenced. I told myself the plea was fine, a good deal, a reasonable deal. I told myself that for three years.”

Bernie did not say anything. For a woman who talks like a sitcom, she has a gift for silence.

“I’m going up there,” I said.

“Tomorrow.”

“Tomorrow. Before I lose my nerve, and before somebody else tells him first.”

I drove at six the next morning, with a thermos of Bernie’s coffee and a folder on the passenger seat. It was three hours north, up through the coal-colored hills, the highway running between bare trees and barns slumped like sleeping cattle. The State Correctional Institution at Marlow Ridge sits on a ridge, like the name says, behind two fences and a field of brown grass that was frosted white at nine in the morning.

I had a visitor form, my bar card, and the single worst feeling I have ever driven toward.

The desk officer was a woman in her fifties with half-glasses on a chain, and she handled my paperwork with the unhurried tenderness of someone who has watched a thousand people try to look calm. She typed. She frowned at her screen. She typed again.

“Ms. Raman. Mabry, Terrence. Inmate number ends in six-one-four?”

“That’s him.”

She took off the half-glasses and set them on the counter. “I’m sorry, hon. He was told you were here. He declined the visit.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!