Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 8

Nobody Underwater

Nell told the story with both hands empty.

Tessa placed the recorder on the table, out of reach of any tab or slot. Della sat by the windows. The resort manager had asked her to remain away from the equipment until someone came to collect her keys. She had agreed with the weary politeness of a person being inconvenienced by a misunderstanding.

Nell moved her chair until she could see the doorway without turning away from Tessa. The recorder’s red light was too small to look consequential. She had seen one almost identical at her last contract, balanced on a stack of unused certificates while instructors argued about lunch expenses.

“Can we do this without her here?” she asked.

Tessa glanced toward the windows. Della was close enough to hear them but no longer close enough to touch the table.

“We can ask her to wait outside. Is that what you want?”

Nell took too long to answer. The director already knew the part of her story that could be made flattering. Nell wanted to tell the rest to someone who did not.

“She can hear it. I don’t want her answering for me.”

Tessa relayed that condition. Della said she understood. Nell could not tell whether she did, and they could not spend the remainder of the afternoon establishing it to everybody’s satisfaction.

Tessa asked what Nell meant the recording to be used for. Nell began with a polished answer about the sequence of events. Tessa waited until she stopped.

“To correct what I left out,” Nell said.

“Then if you want to stop, say stop. It doesn’t make the earlier part disappear.”

Nell nodded. She had been looking for a stretch of time long enough to get everything said without interruption. Now the possibility of interruption was part of the terms. She put her palms flat, changed her mind, and let them rest loosely in her lap.

“Eleven years ago,” Nell began.

“The actual date,” Tessa said.

Nell supplied it. She gave Ruth’s full name, the name of their training company, Quarryline, the quarry location on the old course map. Not a famous accident. Not a story strangers told each other. A small professional world had closed around the people who survived it and gone on using the same chairs.

She first placed the warning after the last demonstration. Then she remembered the supervisor still had his jacket on during the demonstration and had taken it off before the warning. The remembered jacket did not prove a time. Nell stopped and said she was uncertain about that part of the order.

Tessa did not supply a sequence. She asked which parts mattered to the decision Nell had made.

“I knew what Ruth meant. I knew it before I stopped trying to make someone listen.”

Nell could hold that without holding the minute around it. The quarry day’s later shape had become so familiar she had begun to remember the report instead of the morning. In the report, events followed one another neatly enough to be read aloud. Outside the report there had been a wet glove caught on a buckle, somebody asking for a dry pencil, Ruth’s irritation that Nell had borrowed her gloves and returned them rolled together while damp.

Nell had resented being corrected in front of the group. She had expected to be the one who got things right that day. It was easier to remember wanting to help than to remember that small mean hope: that Ruth would need a correction too.

She said that on the recording. Della shifted at the window. Nell looked at her, then back to Tessa before the movement could become permission to qualify what she had said.

“I don’t know whether it affected what I did,” she added. “I know I was irritated. I left that out too.”

She stopped when she heard herself say the exercise had gone wrong.

“That’s too vague,” she said.

Tessa waited.

“Ruth gave the stop signal. I recognized it. The supervisor said the exercise was complete, that the signals we were hearing were part of the equipment recovery. I wanted that to be true.”

She could remember the cold lip of the quarry, the damp cuffs of her sleeves. She remembered irritation too. Ruth was making them late. The shameful thing was not that she had failed to love her friend enough. It was how easily a friend’s urgent need could become an interruption when someone in authority offered another explanation.

“How long did you wait?”

“I can’t give you a precise number. Longer than I should have. I went back after I saw her glove come loose. They had to pull me out. That part’s in the report.”

“The signal isn’t?”

“No.”

“Did you tell the investigators?”

“I said there’d been confusion.”

Tessa looked down at the recorder, checking that it was still running. Nell was grateful for the pause and angry at being grateful. She had wanted to tell the truth as one continuous act, get through it before somebody asked a better question.

“There was confusion,” she said. “But I used that word to hide the part I was sure about.”

Tessa asked whether Nell had ever corrected her account privately. Nell had told herself she had, many times. Alone in a car, on a walk, while waiting for a kettle, she had said the missing sentence without making a sound.

“Not to somebody who could act on it.”

“Did you try?”

“I opened messages. I didn’t send them.”

She remembered one draft to Ruth’s sister, written so carefully that it began with concern and reached the omitted warning only after the screen had filled twice. She had deleted it because it seemed cruel to introduce doubt after the family had already received an investigation. That had been partly true. She had liked how closely the partly true reason protected the rest.

Tessa reached for the recorder and paused. “Do you need a break?”

Nell wanted to say no. Finishing in one uninterrupted sitting would let her count something as done. Her hands had tightened on her trousers without permission from that ambition; she had been attending to them instead of hearing the question.

“Yes.”

Tessa stopped the recorder and said the time aloud before the light went out. Nell asked for water in the plastic cup with a lid. Tessa put it in a shallow tray so it could fall without reaching the floor. Nell held the cup with both hands and drank, attending to each part. They did not discuss whether she was brave. After a few minutes she put the cup down and asked Tessa to start again.

Della shifted in her chair.

“Most people wouldn’t have gone back.”

Nell turned to her. “That isn’t what we’re measuring.”

The old evaluation lay inside Tessa’s bag. The tab was now inside the model. Nell had finally separated the form from the event, and the separation offered no relief she could use.

She continued until there was nothing left she could remember honestly. She described Ruth’s impatience, the private wrist gesture, an argument over borrowed gloves the previous week. She distinguished what she remembered from what she had reconstructed over years of thinking about it. Tessa asked her to repeat that distinction once, more plainly.

Della waited until the recorder had been running again for several minutes.

“The people who decided the exercise was over had more responsibility than you,” she said.

“They did.”

Tessa looked up. Nell had expected herself to argue, to make the admission more complete by accepting everything. She thought of the tab in Model C’s chest and the director’s fingers delivering it.

“I wasn’t the only person who should have listened. That doesn’t remove what I heard.”

“And you went back.”

“Yes. I won’t change that into a lie to make the other part simpler.”

She had been pulled out with nothing useful in her hands. Remembering the attempt did not undo the delay, but denying it would be another way to edit the day into something a listener could judge quickly. Nell let both facts remain on the table. Della no longer looked comforted by their common vocabulary.

Outside, a car door slammed. Nell heard Tessa’s attention move briefly toward it, then return. The manager would arrive when he could. They had already made copies. For the moment no one needed Nell to keep talking except the part of her that had spent eleven years looking for an acceptable place to stop.

Tessa asked one more question before ending the recording.

“Who taught you the private signal?”

“Ruth.”

“Who was using it today?”

“Me, possibly. We can check your video.”

They checked. At the bottom of the frame, Nell’s little finger touched her wrist while she described how a partner could get an instructor’s attention. She had been talking about making signals unmistakable. The irony did not improve the picture. They saved the relevant seconds with the full recording, including the part where the camera tilted toward the ceiling light.

The first playback was too small. Tessa enlarged the image until Nell’s hand occupied most of the screen. Pixels blurred its edges. At that size, any movement could be made to look deliberate.

“Back one,” Nell said.

Tessa returned to the wider frame. The ceiling light flashed. Nell appeared at the bottom, speaking to somebody outside the picture. Her finger touched the wrist, withdrew, and touched it again. Nell remembered explaining partner signals. She had not remembered doing that one.

They watched the stretch before it. Nell’s hand had been empty, her sleeve pushed clear, no strap or watch where her finger went. Then they watched the stretch afterward, to see whether the gesture was a repeated adjustment rather than part of the demonstration. It did not recur in that minute. The recording could not show all the minutes beyond it.

Tessa kept the original file on her phone. Nell’s first impulse was to name a shorter copy with the word proof. She changed the name to the time shown on the full recording instead.

“Did you ever say the meaning out loud today?” Tessa asked.

“I don’t remember doing it before it moved.”

“That’s different from no.”

“Yes.”

Nell wrote down the question rather than answering it more firmly. On the trolley Model C’s vest rose and settled with a steady patience they had not taught it to deserve. It had seen a hand complete a movement while an instructor explained how movements carried meaning. That was enough to complicate the idea of a stolen memory without making the memory harmless.

It was a route by which the model could have learned the gesture. It was not proof of what else it contained. Nell wrote exactly that, then stopped adding qualifications long enough to hear Tessa.

“You didn’t imagine it,” Tessa said. “And you don’t have to decide it’s your friend because it knows something.”

Nell had been holding those as the only choices. She let herself consider the space between them.

When she finished, the room remained a room.

Her fingers did not recover. Model C did not speak Ruth’s name. Kit did not call to say he could breathe. The truth had reached a recording device. It had not negotiated with whatever lay beneath the gray patchwork surface.

Nell tried to turn her phone facedown and nearly let it slide out between her fingers. Tessa stopped it against a folded towel, then left it flat. No sound came from the model. There was no small corresponding motion she could use to pretend the loss had become understandable.

She put her hands back in her lap.

“Did you expect that to help?” Tessa asked.

“With the models?”

“With anything.”

Nell watched the red light until she could answer without looking past the question.

“I expected to feel less occupied by it.”

“And?”

“I can still feel my hands.”

Tessa nodded once. She stopped the recorder. It was an ending to the recording, something limited enough to be true. Nell could not use it as an ending to the rest.

“Who gets that?” Tessa asked.

“The people reviewing this. The original investigation, if there’s a way to add it. Ruth’s sister, if she’ll accept it.”

“Don’t send it to her without asking first.”

Nell nodded. Even confession could be made into a task somebody else was expected to receive gratefully. She recorded a separate short message asking for contact, without attaching the file, and sent it to the address she still had. It might no longer work. She marked that in her notes instead of treating the send as delivery.

The message stayed in the sent folder. No reply appeared. Nell checked the address against the last contact, resisting the urge to search for another route into the woman’s afternoon. If the address failed, she could ask how to pass along a request. She could not make the request urgent merely because she had finally become ready to send it.

Tessa’s phone lit on the table. A short message from the outside contact confirmed the men were still receiving attention; Nell was to keep the existing number available and call about any further change. Tessa read it out, then asked whether Nell wanted her own hand reported in the same terms again.

“Only if you have something new to add.”

“I don’t.”

“Then leave them time.”

Nell heard the impatience in her answer. It had been directed at the screen without a reply, and Tessa had received it. She said that plainly. Tessa nodded, put her phone away, and pulled her chair around to face Nell. The next part of their conversation would not be passed through a recorder or a director.

Tessa saved the full recording in the shared folder.

“Here’s what I need,” she said. “If you recognize something, tell me when it happens. If you’re guessing, say so. If I tell you to stop, you don’t make me prove I’m right first.”

“All right.”

“And stop thanking me when you want me to agree.”

Nell shut her mouth. The thank-you had been coming automatically. She could lose a grip before she lost that habit.

On the trolley, Model C released the ball.

It fell to the tiles and rolled under the table. Tessa moved her foot out of its path. The model’s fingers remained open. There was no tab in anyone’s hand, no spoken completion. Nell waited, counting silently until she realized that counting had become a way to pretend she controlled the length of uncertainty.

“It let go,” Tessa said.

“Yes.”

“You didn’t tell it to.”

“No.”

The gray hand moved toward the other wrist. Two taps. Then a scrape of air came from the patched mouth.

“You always make me go first.”

Nell’s shoulders tightened before she understood the words. Ruth had said that at the quarry, making an ugly face while Nell checked the list. She had said it about introductions at a professional dinner too, about asking for a refund, about being the one who knocked when a neighbor’s music got loud. Nell had remembered it as a joke because that made her easier to live with.

“That’s something Ruth said,” she told Tessa.

“Does that mean it’s her?”

The model’s mouth remained open. Its breathing was steady, borrowed, a fact she could neither forgive nor explain away.

“I don’t know. It could have learned what I carried into the demonstration.”

“Then don’t ask it to prove a person to you.”

Nell looked at the ball under the table. The model had accepted her catching lesson and then done something the lesson hadn’t required. It had released what it had learned to hold.

“What if a rescue needs someone who can refuse it?” she said.

Tessa followed her gaze. “That’s a question. Keep it one.”

Nell opened a fresh page. For the first time that day, she wrote a proposed action without leaving a box beside it for the result.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!