Willa
I cheated on my hearing test, and I would like it noted that I was very good at it for about ninety seconds.
On Thursday morning in Denver, a mile above the sea, every breath I took on the walk from the rented car to the clinic was half a breath, and every thought I had was slightly out of focus at the edges. The building was brick, five stories, with a lobby the color of weak tea.
Jude had driven me there in a rented car and stayed in the lot with the engine running, because I had told him that if he came inside I would do something we’d both regret in the news.
The insurer’s audiologist was named Dr. Marian Ellis. She was in her fifties, with reading glasses on a chain and a voice like a librarian who is also paying a mortgage. She put me in a booth with foam walls, the third such booth of my life, and said, “Press the button when you hear the tone, however faint. Even if you think you imagined it.”
I put on the headphones and I stopped being Willa Mercer and started being a drummer at a test.
The tones came in pulses. A second of silence, a thin tone, another silence, longer, another tone. Silence is a measurement, and I have been measuring it since I was nine. By the second frequency I had found the pulse inside her randomness, the faint hitch where her hand went to the dial, and I started to press early. Before the tone. On the beat I knew was coming. The little green line on the other side of the glass drew itself straight and high and perfect.
I would like to say I felt bad. I felt like a woman getting away with something.
Dr. Ellis opened the door of the booth.
“Ms. Mercer,” she said, kindly, “you pressed twice in the gap.”
“I’m sorry?”
“The silence. You pressed in it, before the tone arrived. A person who hears a thing doesn’t need to guess when it’s coming.” She took off her glasses. “It’s the drummers. We get one a year. I randomize the intervals for exactly this. Would you like to try again, honestly?”
I sat in the foam box and listened to my own breath. A thin wire sang in my left ear, as it does in a quiet room, and I understood that it had been singing the whole time.
“Yes,” I said.
So I tried again, and this time I pressed only when I heard it, and in the left ear I heard almost nothing. Whole stretches went by of tones I knew were coming and could not find, like trying to see a star by staring at it. She tested my words next, a man’s voice in a hiss of noise like rain, and I wrote “wishing” for “fishing,” and “bay” for “base,” and I got sixty percent.
“Fifty decibels at four thousand hertz in the left,” said Dr. Ellis, afterward, in a small, clean office with a plant. “A further drop from your June baseline. Right ear, moderate. I’m obliged to report that you’re not cleared to perform amplified percussion. Any quieter vocal role would need a separate plan and clearance.”
She laid her glasses on the desk. “I’m going to say one thing that isn’t in the report. That’s a good ear. It’s a good ear you’ve been asking to work for a living in a very loud place. It would like a different job.”
“Thank you,” I said. “For the honest test.”
“Thank you for the second one,” said Dr. Ellis, and she shook my hand.
Preston Gault was waiting in the lobby, in a chair, with a lawyer on either side and a paper cup of tea balanced on his knee. He rose when I came out. His face was arranged in an expression of deep and personal sorrow.
“Ms. Mercer. I am so sorry. I did hope.”
“You hoped.”
“The Guarantor’s paperwork is a formality now. The exclusion takes effect at midnight Friday night.”
He spread his hands. “I see no reason Denver shouldn’t go ahead tonight, of course. I do love a farewell. But Duluth, I’m afraid, is another matter. A policy that excludes the drummer is a policy that excludes the show, and a tour in default is a tour in default, and then the Reversion, well.” He sighed. “You understand. I hold no ill will. In fact, it’s worth saying that your friend did everything he could.”
“My friend.”
“Mr. Harlan. He came to my office in Los Angeles. He signed five records and ten years to Brasswell, exclusive, on the strength of my promise to ask the Guarantor to waive this exam. I did ask. They declined.” He looked, for a moment, almost sincere. “He didn’t tell you? Oh, dear.”
I do not remember the walk to the parking lot. I remember the light, thin and bright and indifferent, and the cold air going into me in half-breaths, and the rental car with its engine running, and Jude’s face through the windshield as he saw mine.
I got out of the car again, because I was not going to say it in a car.
“You signed ten years.”
He turned the engine off. He got out. He stood on my right, which is where I’d put him, and I almost laughed at the unfairness of that. “Wil, it was only me. Only me I was spending.”
“That’s the sentence.” My voice came out low. “That’s the sentence that gets people killed, Jude. I said it in your apartment. I said it over your bank statements.”
“I thought if I asked him—”
“You asked a man who sells things. And you didn’t ask me.”
“You didn’t tell me about the clinic.” His voice cracked. “Gault told me about the form. Under hearing loss, you wrote No. And Birdie told me you’d gone somewhere, and you said it was nothing, and I said good, because I wanted it to be.”
“You knew I lied.”
“I knew you lied about the form. You lied about Albuquerque too. Didn’t you.”
“It’s twelve decibels worse.” The words came out in a flat rush. “In three months. Dr. Ellis says fifty. I said nothing because I knew exactly what you’d do. You’d cut the cap. You’d call Dot. You’d decide.”
“And you decided I couldn’t be trusted with the number.”
“Yes! Yes, because you’d proved it!”
A woman walking a dog crossed the street to get away from us. I did not care. I had been holding my own weight for three years and had just discovered it was somebody else’s.
“You never ask,” Jude said, quietly.
“And you never wait to be asked.” I was crying now, hard, in the way that makes your face hurt. “We take turns, don’t we. You decide, and then I decide, and we call it love. We are the same disease, Jude. We’re two people who’d rather break a thing than hand it over.” I wiped my face with the heel of my hand. “I’m done. I can’t do twelve shows of this.”
“Wil—”
“Not walking. I’m not walking, I’m playing tonight. But don’t talk to me.”
I played Denver that night, and it was the best show of my life.
I knew it was the last one. I knew it in my wrists. I played every fill I had invented since I was nineteen, the Fargo one, the one off the second album, the four-note hiccup that now lived in somebody else’s hit. The cymbals shimmered in a room I could not hear. In the second chorus of “Lighthouse Hours” I sang my line to the back of the hall, and four thousand people were so quiet I felt the quiet land on me like snow.
Jude stood on my right all night and never turned his head. I never looked at him. In the last bar, I hit the final crash with everything left in my arms, and held my stick up, and let the sound go.
Back in my hotel room, I laid my molds on the bedside table and listened. No amplifiers. No monitor mix. The room was not silent. It was a room with a record playing in another house, far away, the bass of it faintly there and the top gone, and the wire in my left ear laying its one thin note over everything.
On Dot’s door, I left a note: Not walking. Going home. Duluth, Saturday, five o’clock. Don’t follow me. Please.
I put my palm flat on the mattress, the way I’d stood at the lamppost in New Orleans, and waited for a beat.
There wasn’t one.

