Jude
Willa did not speak to me for the entire length of Michigan, which would have been restful if she hadn’t done it so loudly.
Detroit was the best show of the tour. Anger is a very good tempo. She held the groove like a woman leaning on a door against weather, and I sang a whole step down into her right side and she never once turned her head, and afterward Birdie said, “Ninety-one. You’re welcome,” and walked away before I could ask what for.
We reached Nashville at seven in the morning, parked behind a venue the size of a hangar. The city still believed it was August. Marlene’s door sighed open and the heat came in like a dog that had been waiting on the step.
At half past nine the curtain on my bunk moved. Willa was standing there with her arms folded and her hair wet.
“True thing,” she said. “For Nashville. I want to see where you went.”
“That’s not a true thing. That’s a request.”
“It’s a true thing that I want it.”
You cannot argue with a drummer about time. I took her across the river in a ride-hailing car that smelled of vanilla, and we did not speak, and she stared out the window at the city as if she were pricing it.
I live on the third floor of a brick building in East Nashville, over a tire shop with a mural of a catfish wearing sunglasses. There is no elevator. By the second landing Willa had stopped being angry and started being a woman at the scene of a crime, reading everything: the cracked tile, the neighbor’s bicycle, the smell of someone else’s onions.
“It’s small,” she said, at the door.
“Fun fact: it was cheaper than a therapist.”
She stepped inside and stopped.
I had cleaned. Before leaving for Duluth, I had cleaned for two days in a way that would have embarrassed a surgeon. It hadn’t helped. A futon, a window unit rattling at full effort, a kitchen with one pan. And in the corner by the window, set up under a framed photograph of the Duluth Lift Bridge, a practice pad on a stand, a secondhand drum kit with a towel draped over the snare, and a cup of hickory sticks with the tips worn flat as thumbs.
Willa looked at the kit for a long time.
“Whose is that?”
“A hobby.”
“You hate hobbies. You tried to take up chess and quit when you lost to Rafe’s cousin.”
“He was twelve.”
She turned. On the wall above the futon hung a gold record. Brass plate, black matting, a name I had never once said aloud in her presence. She walked over and read it the way she reads a contract.
“Joelle Rourke,” she said. “‘Four Hundred Miles of Maybe.’ Written by Linden Hale.”
“My mother’s maiden name was Hale,” I said. “And there’s a Linden Street in Silver Bay. It’s a pen name. I write songs for other people. Joelle is twenty-four and has never once asked who I am. It’s the best working relationship I’ve ever had.”
“You wrote this?” From the tire shop below, through the floor, a radio was playing, and for a bar I could swear the universe was in on it. It was her song. The chorus of “Four Hundred Miles of Maybe” came up through the boards, and Willa’s head turned toward the floor like a compass needle.
Then she heard it, under the vocal. The four-note fill. Snare, snare, tom, tom, a little hiccup at the end.
“That’s mine,” she said.
“Fun fact,” I said. “It’s four notes.”
“It’s my four notes. It’s the fill from ‘Wake the Neighbors.’ I invented it in a van outside Fargo and I’ve been hitting it every night for six years.”
“I always put your name on everything we wrote.”
“On everything we wrote,” said Willa. “Not on this.”
I had no answer. It was the only song of the eleven I’d placed that I’d let myself steal from. She knew it. I knew she knew it. Neither of us said the sentence that goes next.
She wandered the room like a woman looking for the exit. On the counter, under a jar of guitar picks, lay a stack of envelopes with the Brasswell crest. I saw her see them, and I saw her hand go out, and I opened my mouth, and Rule Seven closed it for me. There is no rule for what happens in daylight.
“Remittance advice,” she read. “Payment received. Forty-one thousand dollars.” She flipped the next one. And the next. “Thirty. Fifty-two. Forty. Dot said the balance came down as a gesture of goodwill.”
“Dot says a lot of things.”
“You paid this.” She said it flatly. She did not look up. “The four point one that was ours. You paid down one point seven million dollars.”
“I paid more than that. There’s interest.”
“For three years I thought you’d walked out on a debt and left me standing in it.” Her voice had dropped, which is what her voice does when it is about to lift something heavy. “I was proud of that. I was proud to be standing in it. It was the only thing I had that was mine.”
“It was supposed to be only mine.”
“That’s the sentence that gets people killed, Jude.”
She put the envelopes down, very square, the way she squares a stack of paper behind her father’s counter. Then she did the thing I had hoped for and dreaded for three years. She crossed the room to the corner by the window, sat down on the stool at the practice pad, and picked up a pair of my sticks.
“Show me,” she said.
“I can’t.”
“You’ve been learning my parts. Show me.”
So I stood there, thirty-four years old, in a hot room above a catfish, and played the first four bars of “Lighthouse Hours” on a rubber pad, badly. My left hand went where it wanted. My right hand arrived late. It sounded like a man falling down a staircase with a bag of cutlery.
Willa listened with her eyes closed. When it was over, she said, “Your left hand is a crime.”
“I know.”
“Give me your wrist.”
She stood behind me and fitted her hand over mine on the stick, and moved my fingers, the old way, the fulcrum between thumb and forefinger, the stick a thing you hold like a bird, not like a hammer. I could feel her breathing near my ear, steady and slow. I could smell the lake still in her hair. I did not move. I have been still in the middle of a lot of things in my life, but never like that.
“There,” she said, very quietly. “That’s not a crime. That’s a misdemeanor.”
“Wil.”
“Don’t.”
Her hand stayed where it was for one beat. Then it left, and the room got hot all at once.
“My true thing is over,” she said. “I’ve seen the place. You can have yours. And I’m going to ask you one thing, and it’s not a question, it’s a rule. Don’t say you’re sorry.”
“I’m not,” I said.
She went still.
“That’s my true thing for Nashville. I’m not sorry I left.” It came out of me raw, like something dragged up from a lake. “I’m sorry how. I would do the leaving again. I would do it so differently. But I’d do it.”
The window unit rattled. Down in the tire shop, the radio moved on to something else.
“That,” said Willa, “is the worst true thing you have ever said.”
She walked to the door. I didn’t stop her, because I had learned in my own hard school that you don’t stop a woman who has finally decided how to leave a room. I heard her go down three flights, one hand skidding on the rail, and then the street door, and then nothing.
I looked at the pad. There was a stick lying across it, one of her pair from her back pocket, set down there, I thought, like a hand. Her left-hand stick, the one with the black tape on the shoulder. Willa Mercer has never in her life forgotten a stick.
I held it for a long time. Then I put it in the cup with mine, which is as close as I have ever come to a hope.

