Jude
A deposition is a concert with no audience, no band, and one song, and the song is the word yes.
I learned that on the twenty-second floor of a Minneapolis office building, in a conference room with a long walnut table, a pitcher of water nobody touched, and a window that looked down on the river as it ran gray under the first ice. It was eleven days after the finale. The snow on Duluth had finally stopped. I had slept four hours, in Hank Mercer’s sewing room, under a quilt that smelled of cedar and lavender.
“Rules of the road,” Teddy Brandt had said in the elevator, in the voice of a woman reading a cereal box. “Listen to the question. Answer that question. Do not volunteer. Do not be charming. Do not, under any circumstances, say fun fact.”
“I’ve been working on it.”
“Work harder. Every joke you make is a tenth of an hour, and the court reporter will type it.”
The court reporter was a woman named Bernadette with gray braids and fingers like a pianist’s. She raised her hand, and I raised mine, and I swore to tell the truth, and for the first time in years the oath felt like a thing I could keep.
Across the table sat Hollis Crane, counsel for Brasswell Records, a lean man of about fifty-five in a charcoal suit, with a fountain pen and a soft, unhurried voice, the voice of a man who has been courteous to a great many people on their worst days. Preston Gault was not in the room. I had looked for him anyway. I had looked in the corners the way you look under the bed.
“Mr. Harlan,” said Crane, “thank you for coming. Can you state your name?”
“Jude Michael Harlan.”
“And you also write songs under the name Linden Hale.”
“Yes.”
“Since when?”
“Three years and one month.”
For the first forty minutes he asked me about music, and it was almost restful. He asked me when I first heard the four-note fill. I said I couldn’t tell him the day, and that it was Willa’s. He asked whether I had used it in eleven songs. I said yes. He asked whether I had told anyone at Brasswell Publishing that I was using it. I said I had told a man in the publishing department named Dale, in an email, that I was “borrowing from a friend,” and that Dale had written back, “Fine.”
“You were borrowing from Ms. Mercer.”
“Yes.”
“Did you ask her permission?”
“No.”
“Why not?”
I looked at Teddy. She did not move. “Because I wasn’t speaking to her,” I said. “And because I was afraid she would say yes. And I didn’t want a yes I hadn’t earned.”
Crane wrote it down with his fountain pen, which struck me as theater, since Bernadette had already typed it. “That’s very candid.”
“It’s the only kind I’ve got now.”
“Mr. Harlan, I’d like to ask about your reasons for leaving the band.”
“Objection,” said Teddy, pleasantly. “Relevance.”
“It goes to motive and to the state of the relationship at the time the Hale catalog began,” said Crane. “Go ahead, Mr. Harlan.”
So I told him. I did not make a joke. I said I had found a medical letter in a cymbal bag the night before the last show of a long tour; that I had understood Ms. Mercer’s hearing to be at risk; that I had believed she would never stop herself while the band existed; that I had decided to end the band so she would not be the one to stop. I said all of it in plain words, one after the other, like a man putting down bricks. The room did not do what I expected, which was to get warmer. It got colder and cleaner, like a room after the heat has been shut off.
“And that decision,” said Crane. “You made it alone.”
“Yes.”
“Without consulting her.”
“Yes. It was wrong.”
“Move to strike the last sentence as non-responsive,” said Crane, mildly.
“No,” said Teddy. “Leave it in. It’s the best thing he’s said all morning.”
Crane turned a page. He had a way of turning pages that made you think you were being given a gift. “Mr. Harlan, I’m going to read you something and ask whether you recall it. On October twenty-ninth of that year, in an office on Walnut Street in Philadelphia, did you say the following words: ‘She will never stop on her own. So I have to make her hate me. It’s the only door she can’t follow me through’?”
I did not breathe.
The window gave me back my own face, thin and gray against the river.
I had said those words. I had said them in exactly that order, at four in the afternoon, in a leather chair, with a box of tissues on the desk and a man I had been told I could trust writing nothing down because he said it was safer. The man had said, “Mr. Harlan, nothing you say in this room leaves it.” I remembered the smell of lemon polish. I remembered that I had, for the first time in two days, begun to cry.
Two people had been in that room.
“Objection,” said Teddy, and her voice had changed. It was low and flat and utterly pleasant. “Foundation. Privilege. Mr. Crane, I would like you to tell me where you obtained that sentence.”
“I’ll withdraw the question.”
“I don’t want it withdrawn. I want it sourced.”
“Then I’ll move on,” said Crane, with the faint smile of a man who has opened a window and shut it again, and, having let a little weather in, is satisfied. “Mr. Harlan, I’d like to turn to Plaintiff’s Exhibit Nine.”
He slid a single sheet across the walnut. I knew it before I read it, the way you know the first chord of a song you’ve been avoiding. A questionnaire. At the top, the name of a bonding company in Denver, a long number, and, in blue ink, a signature round and square at once, the signature of a woman who has never in her life wanted to be a patient.
Hearing loss, diagnosed or suspected? the form said. And beside it, a neat, firm, honest-looking box, checked No.
“Do you recognize that signature?”
“Yes.”
“Whose is it?”
“Willa Mercer’s.”
“And do you know whether, at the time she signed it in July, Ms. Mercer had been diagnosed with hearing loss?”
Teddy put her hand flat on the table. “Don’t answer.”
“I’m asking,” said Crane gently, “because Brasswell, together with the completion guarantor, filed a motion this morning at nine-fifteen to rescind the Reversion. The grounds are that the guarantor was induced to issue its policy on a material misrepresentation. If the court agrees, the Reversion is void from the beginning. The masters of Cheap Gold go back to Brasswell Records. The balance of two point four million dollars is reinstated. And I believe, Mr. Harlan, that the guarantor’s schedule on page nineteen is unaffected. You are on it. For all of it.”
“For all of it,” I said.
“And Ms. Mercer is on it for you.”
That was the part that took the floor out. It was the part I had written “all” to prevent. Every time I had tried to carry the whole weight alone, I had put it on her.
“I’d like the record to reflect,” said Teddy, “that Mr. Harlan is not answering.”
“The record will reflect that,” said Crane, and nodded to Bernadette. “Please type it.”
I looked at the river, which had stopped being gray and become a thin gold line under the last of the light. I thought: I had finally learned to ask, and I had been asking the wrong things. I had asked how to be good. I should have asked how to be careful.
Bernadette typed. Under her fingers, in the quiet, I could hear each key land, a soft, quick, relentless pulse. Four notes. Four more. She typed the whole sentence without once looking up, and I listened to every word of it go into the record.
The masters of Cheap Gold go back to Brasswell Records.

