Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 11

Exhibit F

Willa

Dot read the complaint in the wings of the Ore Dock Pavilion with a ruler under each line, while four thousand people we had just made cry were still stamping their boots in the lobby.

I stood in my molds with my stick bag on my shoulder and the snow melting out of my hair. Rafe sat on a road case with his bass across his knees and his face the color of oatmeal. Paloma had a phone in each hand and was reading something aloud to herself, moving her lips. Jude stood on my right. I had told him he could. It still felt like being handed a hot plate.

“Count one,” Dot said, in the monotone. “Declaratory judgment that the four-note percussion figure known as the Fill, first recorded on the album Wake the Neighbors, is Fill Material under the Contributor’s Acknowledgment executed June of that year, and is therefore the property of Brasswell Records.”

“June of which year?” I said.

“Eleven years ago.” She turned the page. “Count two. The song catalog written by one L. Hale, also known as Jude Harlan, uses the Fill in eleven compositions. Brasswell demands an accounting of all earnings, which they estimate at six point three million dollars, plus an injunction against further use.”

“Six point three,” Jude said, faintly, the way a man reads a diagnosis.

“Count three is the one I enjoy.” Dot peeled a toothpick out of her pocket and did not put it in her mouth. “Defendant Number Two, Willa Mercer, is named as a necessary party, being the co-owner of the Fill and the signatory of Exhibit F.”

“Necessary,” I said. “Nobody has called me that since the sixth grade.”

“I’m choosing to be flattered on your behalf.”

She held out Exhibit F, and I took it and stood in the light of an exit sign and read my own handwriting.

It was a single page, typed, with a line at the bottom. W. Mercer, in blue ink, round and loopy, the signature of a twenty-two-year-old who still dotted her i’s. I remembered the day. We were in a conference room in Minneapolis with a plate of bad cookies, and a man in a vest slid a stack of paper across the table and said, “Initial where the sticky arrows are.” I had initialed where the sticky arrows were. Jude had been in the bathroom. Dot had been on the phone. Nobody had said the word acknowledgment.

“I never asked what it was,” I said.

“No,” said Dot gently. “You didn’t.”

It was the most deserved sentence anyone had ever said to me. I had spent three years refusing to ask Jude one question, and eleven years refusing to ask one man in a vest.

The phone in Dot’s other hand buzzed. She put it on speaker and set it on top of the amp case, and a woman’s voice said, dry as a cracker, “Teddy Brandt. I’m in a car in Minneapolis, it’s past midnight, and I bill in tenths of an hour. That sentence just cost you point one.”

“This is the lawyer,” Dot told us. “I went to law school with her sister. She’s the best I know and she is not nice.”

“I’m very nice,” said Teddy Brandt. “I’m nice to people who answer the question I ask. Who’s Willa?”

“Here,” I said.

“Willa, stop talking to anybody. I mean it. Not Brasswell, not a reporter, not a man at a hardware store who says he’s a fan. In the morning I’ll want to know three things: where that fill came from, when, and who else was in the room. Don’t answer tonight. Sleep.”

“I’m going to sleep,” I said. “I’m just going to do it at my father’s house.”

“Is your father hard of hearing?”

“Yes,” I said, and then I laughed, once, because I had said it without flinching. “Why?”

“Because you’re about to say some things at that house you wouldn’t say at mine.” She hung up.

Hank Mercer lives on a hill in West Duluth in a narrow gray house his own father built, with a woodstove, a porch light that has never been off since 1991, and a kitchen where nobody has ever gone hungry. He met us at the door in his cardigan with his glasses pushed up on his forehead.

“I made up two beds,” he said. “Separate rooms. The one with the quilt and the one with the sewing machine.”

“Dad.”

“WHAT?”

“I said thank you!”

“I’m not that deaf,” said Hank. He looked at Jude, at his boots, at the snow on his shoulders, and added in a lower voice, the one he used for customers about to make a mistake with a drill bit, “Ask her before you sit on anything, son.”

I went up to my old room alone. It still had the poster of a band that broke up in 1998, and a dent in the wall at drummer’s height where I had once lost an argument with a stick. I took out my molds and set them on the nightstand in their little case. Then I did what I had done every night for two weeks, which was lie on my right side with my good ear up and listen to the house.

The house was quiet, and the quiet was not quiet. It was a hum, high and thin, a wire pulled taut across my left side. After four thousand people and a stage, the tinnitus always came in like the tide. I counted. One, two, three, four. One, two, three, four. A woman at a clinic in Denver had said it might ease in a week. She had not said it would be a pleasant week.

There was a knock, so soft that I felt the door move more than heard it.

“Wil?” Jude said through the wood. “It’s me. I’m not coming in. I just wanted to ask if I could.”

I lay there. My heart was going about ninety.

“Which part?” I said. “Coming in, or sitting?”

“Either. Both. At the end of the bed. I’ll stay on the floor if you want.”

I did not tell him to go away. That was how I knew I had changed. “You can sit,” I said. “On my right. And you can’t talk about the case.”

“Deal.”

He came in with the door open six inches, the way you do in a house where a father is listening. He sat at the foot of the bed on the right side with his boots off, and for a long time we said nothing, and the nothing was easy. Somewhere below us a woodstove ticked.

“Are you scared?” he asked.

“Yes. Are you?”

“Fun fact,” said Jude, and then he stopped himself. “No. Yes. I’m so scared I can’t feel my hands, and I’m also the happiest I’ve been in three years, and I don’t know where to put both of those.”

“Put them on the nightstand,” I said. “Next to the plugs.”

He laughed, and I felt it through the mattress. Then he said, “May I hold your foot?” and I said yes, and he held it through the quilt as if it were a thing that might break, and I fell asleep in under a minute for the first time since Denver, with a man’s hand around my ankle and a legal complaint in my duffel.

My phone woke me at six. It was an unknown number with a Los Angeles area code, and it was a text.

Good morning, friend. I am sorry you have been pulled into this. You are the one person in the dispute who has done nothing wrong, and I should like to see you out of it. One sentence, signed, and Brasswell will dismiss you with prejudice by noon. No payment asked. No Mr. Harlan involved. I am attaching it. Please read it before you decide I am the villain. -P.G.

The attachment was a half-page. I opened it standing at the window in my socks, with the lake going silver beyond the roofs, and read it three times.

I, Willa Mercer, state that the four-note percussion figure known as the Fill was created by me during the term of my agreement with Brasswell Records and delivered to Brasswell in the course of recording.

That was all. It wasn’t a lie about my ear. It wasn’t a trick. It was one flat sentence, and as far as I could tell, standing there with the cold coming off the glass, it was true. I had made the Fill. I had carried it into a studio. I could not have told a judge otherwise with a straight face.

I had never wanted to sign anything less. It would take me out of the lawsuit and put six point three million dollars on the back of the man asleep, sitting up, at the foot of my bed.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!