By Sunday noon the index cards had spread across both dissection tables in Lab B-004 and begun to colonise the floor.
There were forty-one of them. Zara had insisted on numbering, on the grounds that a question not numbered is a question not asked. They were stuck down with the blue tape we use for labelling jars, and under the cabinet of specimen thirty, in the place where the stair door is, I had put a sticky note that said DO NOT OPEN, which is the kind of sign you only need when you have already opened it.
I had slept four hours. My glass read forty-nine when I checked it on the bench, which was two points below where it had been the night before, and nobody had said it aloud but I could feel it in the way the room was too bright. Eleven points does not sound like much. It is like being told you have lost eleven percent of your own weather.
“Rules,” said Professor Aldous Finch. He had settled into the rolling chair at the head of the tables, which he could no longer quite sit on, so that he hovered an inch above the vinyl with great dignity. Ruth stood at his shoulder with a notepad. “We have three questions. The creature has three. They alternate. It will be asked in good faith and answered, we assume, in the same. We have, I suggest, one chance to do this properly, three times.”
“Calder’s drafted a liability waiver,” said Zara.
“It isn’t a waiver,” said Idris Calder. He had both watches out, side by side on the tray, which is what he does when he is frightened and does not want you to know. “It is an acknowledgment of risk in the nature of a prefatory statement. I would like to say, for the record, that I took this brief because the Wend Hall Watch Trust is paying me by the hour, and not because I have a view about cosmology.”
“It’s a waiver.”
“It is a preliminary instrument,” said Calder, “and I will thank you not to use the other word in front of the client.”
“I’m the client,” I said.
“Yes,” said Calder, with great sympathy. “That is my concern.”
We went through the cards. Some were practical (NUMBER 3: WHAT CAN YOU DO TO A BUILDING? NUMBER 19: CAN YOU HEAR EVERYTHING?). Some were Zara’s and had been written in the manner of a person drafting a hostile deposition (NUMBER 22: RESPECTFULLY, WHAT DID YOU DO WITH THE FIRE?). Calder had contributed eight, each a paragraph long, each ending, “and if so, on what authority.” Ruth had written only one, in a round, careful hand, and had put it face down. Teddy had written none. He had put a half sandwich on the corner of the table and gone to sweep the corridor, and I had understood, from the pace of the broom, that this was his way of saying that he thought we were all being very brave and slightly stupid.
Finch’s contribution was in his own hand, on his own embossed card. It said: *Ask it nothing it cannot afford to answer honestly.*
“Is that a question?” said Zara.
“It is a Courtesy,” said Finch. “Courtesies do not require the interrogative.”
“The trouble,” said Calder, “is that we do not know the cost of the question. Mrs. Lowell paid eleven points of dread for answering one. I should like to know what the cost of asking is.”
“Nothing,” I said. They all looked at me. “It said we ask, it answers, it asks, we answer. It’s the answering that costs. It takes what you give it. I think it takes the fear out of whatever you say, if you say it truly. It said it had never taken anything that wasn’t given.” I rubbed the heel of my hand over my breastbone. “I think the danger isn’t what it asks. It’s that I’ll tell it the truth.”
“Then do not,” said Calder.
“I can’t. It knows.” I looked at the cards. “Honestly, I don’t think I can lie to it. I’ve been trying not to lie to anyone since January. I’ve gotten out of the habit.”
The door of the lab opened.
I thought it was Teddy. It was Constance Ruddock.
She stood in the doorway in her silver bob and her gray wool coat, the brass tuning fork on its chain at her breastbone and, in her left hand, a clear plastic folder the size of a briefcase. In her right she held, with great care, as one holds a sleeping child, a violet in a clay pot. It had one very bright new leaf and four old ones, and it had been, I knew, on the sill of her office in the Wardcraft tower for twenty years, and had never flowered.
“I am told,” said Ruddock, “that you have been talking to the Cordon’s foundation without a licensed ward engineer present.”
“Constance,” said Finch, with enormous pleasure.
“Aldous.” She came in. She set the violet on the dissection table between the index cards and a jar of mixed vertebrae. Her hands, I saw, were not entirely steady, and she looked at them with an expression of mild professional interest, as at a gauge that has begun to read in the wrong direction. “I have not slept. I have been, since Friday, reading the Vane drawings. I did not read them in 1999. I read the tops of the pages, and the notation, and I did not read what she had written between the lines.” She opened the folder. “Mrs. Vane did not install a Quiet. She installed a latch.”
“A latch,” said Calder.
“A latch. In the lattice, at the foot of the stair, here.” She turned the page to face us. It was a ward diagram in a thin brown ink, with a small square drawn in the center of it, and next to the square, in a hand I recognised at once from the margins of Ezra’s notebook, one word. *Closed.* And under it, much smaller, as though added later and with a shaking hand: *Not locked.*
“It is a gate,” said Ruddock. “It has a handle on the inside.” She said the next sentence very precisely, as though she had been practising it in front of a mirror. “It has been, by my reading, the single most irresponsible piece of engineering in the history of the discipline, and I have spent twenty years maintaining it.”
“Constance,” I said. “Are you afraid?”
“I am forty-one,” said Ruddock, “as of this morning.” She did not look at me. “I should prefer not to discuss it. But it is a very unfamiliar sensation and I wish to ask your department for a list of the recognised symptoms.”
Zara, without a word, pushed a mug of tea along the table to her.
We worked for another three hours. We cut the forty-one cards to nine. We cut the nine, over Calder’s agonised objection, to four. We ate Ruth’s ginger cookies, which she had brought in a tin, and Finch watched each one go into someone’s mouth with a kind of placid, wistful interest. At half past three I asked the committee to vote on what I would ask first, and the vote was, by a show of hands, four to three, with Ruddock abstaining, and Finch, who had no hand to raise, saying aloud, “I vote for whichever is least likely to be a mistake,” which helped nobody.
It was Teddy who came back at four. He stood in the lab door with the broom, and he looked, for the first time since I had known him, like a man who had been told something he did not want to say.
“Pippa,” he said. “You’d better come down. Nobody’s been in there since last night. I locked it myself.”
“The Cold Room?”
“I went to check on the little ones.” He took off his cap. “Somebody’s put the stove back on the slate. It’s lit.”

