I had agreed to stay out of the room, and that is the only reason I know what was said in it.
Bart had been very clear. Alone, he had written, and I had kept to it. At a quarter to midnight on Sunday I let him in at the Fenner Street door, and he stood in the lobby with his coat on, and his hands pushed down in the pockets, and asked where the room was, though he knew. I walked him to the Founders’ Room. I turned on one lamp. I said, “I’ll be in the corridor.”
“You don’t have to be.”
“I know. I’d like to be, if that’s all right. I won’t come in. I won’t listen unless it’s too loud to help.” I held up Biscuit, in my glove, as a sort of oath. “He’s very discreet.”
Bart almost smiled. “All right.”
I shut the door to within an inch and sat on the floor in the corridor, with my back against the wall and the heating pipe warm along my spine, and Mortimer, who had come down the stair to see what the fuss was, in my lap. It was not at all the same as listening at a keyhole. It was the thing you do when a person you do not entirely trust is about to talk to someone you love, and you will not leave them alone together, and you are also trying to be good.
For a long time there was no sound. I counted the lamps along the Walk through the window at the end of the corridor. Twelve. I counted the seconds. At four hundred and eleven I heard a chair scrape.
“I am here,” said Bart’s voice, quite low, in the Founders’ Room. “I don’t know how this is done. I think you hear me. I heard you when I was nine, in this room, and I was frightened and I told my mother and she said pipes. I would like to say that I never thought it was pipes. I would like to say that I’m sorry.”
Silence. A beam ticked, up in the ceiling.
“Bartholomew,” said Josiah Wend.
It was a very soft voice. I had not heard him use it. It was the voice, I thought, of a man bending over a bed.
“Yes,” said Bart. His own voice shook. “Yes, that’s my name. Why do you say it? You’ve said it every time. For thirty-eight years.”
“It is the only one I know,” said the builder, “for the one who answers.”
“I don’t understand.”
“I had a brother.” The words came slowly, with a carpenter’s care. “Bartholomew Wend. He was four years my junior and he could not build a chair. He came on the morning after, on the first train he could get, and he found me on my knees in the yard. He did not say a word. He knelt down beside me and he put his arm round my shoulders, and he said nothing for an hour. He was the only man who came to the ashes who did not tell me what I should do.” A pause. “I said to the ground what I said. He heard it. He heard what it answered. He never told, to the end of his life, and he never reproached me.”
“And I’m named for him.”
“You are named for his son. But you have his laugh.” The voice was almost smiling. “You came into this room at nine years of age with a clip-on tie, and you put your ear against my wall, and you laughed because it tickled. I thought, it is Barty. He has come back. He has come to the ashes. I called you. I did not know what else to call.”
I heard a sound I did not at first identify. It was a man in a fleece vest, in a very expensive house, sitting in a high-backed chair, with his hand over his mouth.
“I’m not him,” said Bart, thickly.
“No. I know. I have known it for thirty-eight years.” The beams creaked. “I did not wish to stop. You were the only one who ever listened. Every year I thought, he will go away, and every year you came back. It was very selfish of me. I am sorry for it. I have frightened a child.”
“You didn’t frighten me.” It was not quite true, and Bart knew it, and I heard him know it. “You did. You did, but it wasn’t that. It was that nobody believed me. It was that you were crying and everybody said it was nothing. I thought, I’m the only one who knows, and I can’t do anything. I thought, if I make it stop,” and his voice cracked clean in two. “If I just make it stop.”
“By pulling down the house.”
“Yes.”
“It was kindly meant,” said Josiah. “I should like you to know that I understood it. It is what I should have done at your age. It is, God forgive me, what I did.”
I put my fist against my mouth. Mortimer, in my lap, turned and looked at the door with all his empty attention.
“Is it the house that hurts?” said Bart, very low. “Is it the, is it the building, that’s the cage?”
“No.” It was very firm. “It is not the house. It is a good house. I built it well. It has been afraid for me for a hundred and thirty-nine years and has never once complained.” A beam shifted. “It is the Watch that is the cage, child. It is the order I gave. I said, keep the watch till morning. I said it to nine children, and they kept it, and so have I. And nobody has come, and nobody has said that it is morning, and I do not know how it is said.”
“Neither do I,” said Bart.
“Then we are two,” said the builder. “That is better than one.”
There was a very long silence. I did not move. I do not think I breathed. The twelve lamps outside burned on.
“Mr. Wend,” said Bart at last. “I’m going to say a thing, and I don’t know if it’s right. I’m going to say that I don’t want to tear it down.”
“I know.”
“I don’t. I’ve been telling myself I did. It’s not what I want.” A laugh, wet and broken. “I want it to be quiet. I want to go into a building that belongs to my family and not be afraid of it. And I’d like, I’d like you to stop being alone in it.”
“Child,” said Josiah.
“I’m forty-seven. Don’t call me child.”
“I am a hundred and ninety-four. I shall call you what I like.” It was almost laughter. I put my forehead on my knees. “Bart. It is a good short name. I should have asked for it earlier.”
I do not know how long they sat. A good while. I heard a few things more. I heard Bart ask what it was like, in the walls, and Josiah tell him about the plumb line, and the cold in the north wall in January, and the sound of the first Friday bonfire in 1888 on the quad, when he had thought for one wild moment that the schoolhouse was alight again and had screamed through every beam. I heard Bart say he was sorry. I heard Josiah say, “It was not you.” I heard Bart ask about the whistle, and the long silence that followed.
“That is the Tender’s to hear first,” said the builder at last, heavily. “It is about her office. I will tell her when she has the right to ask.”
“What right?”
“The right of someone who has come to the end of what she can do alone. Which is a place I am afraid she will reach on the twenty-seventh.”
I sat up. My heart did a thing I do not have a word for.
It was a quarter to two when the door opened. I scrambled up. Bart stood in the frame, with his coat on, and his face wet and swollen and rubbed raw, and his sandy hair every which way. He looked about nineteen. He looked, with a force that startled me, like the man in the portrait over the fireplace behind him, the heavy chin, the sad, plain, clever eyes.
“I’m not going to do anything tonight,” he said. His voice was hoarse. “I don’t know what I’m going to do.”
“That’s all right.”
“Is it? I’ve got a petition in front of a judge. I’ve got a lawyer. I’ve got a Trust that’s expecting me to turn up at ten o’clock and say the house should go.” He wiped his face with his sleeve. “I can’t stop it. I don’t think I can. It’s filed. It’s a, if I don’t testify, they’ll just do it, and Hester’s a better lawyer than I’m a trustee.”
“I know.”
“I will still testify.” He said it very quietly. “Ms. Lowell. I’m going to tell the court the truth. I’m going to tell them what I heard. I’m going to tell them exactly what I’ve told you, and I don’t know which of us it helps.” He looked back into the empty room, at the portrait, at the single lamp. “But I think he’d rather be told the truth than be spared.”
“I think he would,” I said.
“I think he’s the only person in my family,” said Bart, “who ever was.”
He went out by the Fenner Street door, alone, into the thin, falling snow. I stood on the step and watched his coat go down the walk under the twelve lit lamps, and I did not feel anything I could have named. It was too big, or too new, or both.
Behind me, in the pipes, Sill said, very softly, “He said his name was short. Is it allowed to like him?”
“I think so,” I said.
“I do,” said the Hall. “I do. I did not expect to.”

