The *Kittiwake Reach* lies at the Sandusky city dock with her bow to the lake and her stern to a parking lot, three hundred and ten feet of white-and-grey survey vessel with a crane on her foredeck and a drill derrick amidships like a church steeple lying on its side.
I went aboard on Thursday morning at eight, with Zara, in hard hats that did not fit, up a gangway that bounced. We were not supposed to be there. Captain Joaquim Fenn had signed us on as “state observers,” a category he said he had made up on the spot and would defend to the death. He met us at the head of the gangway in his windbreaker and a thermal undershirt with a hole in the elbow, and he took us at once down through a steel door, along a corridor that smelled of diesel and floor cleaner, and into a room that said CHART in brass.
It was a small room, panelled, with a table, three screens, a rack of laminated maps, and a coffee machine on which someone had taped a sign reading DO NOT TOUCH. THE CAPTAIN IS FRAGILE. Fenn sat down heavily. I could see now how tired he was. He had the grey, hollowed look of a man who has stood a watch of his own for eleven nights.
“I’ve been at sea thirty-four years,” he said. “Merchant, then survey. I’ve done the Gulf, I’ve done the Great Lakes six seasons. I’m not a superstitious man. I think that’s the first thing I want you to understand, because I’m about to sound like one.”
“You’re among friends,” said Zara.
“The knocking started the night we left Erie. Pennsylvania. Eleven nights ago.” He rubbed his face. “It’s in the hull. Not the engine, I’ve had the engineer check. Not the propeller shaft. It comes up through the plating, forward, below the waterline, in my own cabin first. A rap. A pause. A rap. A pause. Two quick.” He tapped it out on the table, and my glass went from sixty-four to seventy-one. “I thought it was a loose fitting. I had the bosun go over every inch. By the third night, it wasn’t only in my cabin. It was in the mess, and the crew quarters, and the galley. Twelve of the crew went to the company and asked to be taken off. The company said no.”
“Why not?”
“Because the company, Miss Lowell, has a contract with a penalty clause.” He smiled, without humour. “They sent a consultant. A nice young man with a laptop, who spent two nights aboard and said it was cavitation. He went home on the third day. He did not say why.”
“Captain,” I said, “can I ask what the knock does when you answer it?”
He looked at me.
“I beg your pardon?”
“When you knock back. Have you tried it?”
There was a very long pause. The coffee machine ticked. Then Fenn, slowly, with an expression I can only describe as a deep and embarrassed hope, reached out his big sunburned hand and rapped twice on the steel bulkhead beside his chair.
For about five seconds, nothing at all.
Then, from the hull below us, very faint, very polite, there came an answer. Two quick. And a pause. And one, softer, as if to say, *thank you.*
Captain Fenn put his face in his hands.
“I’ve been doing it for six nights,” he said, through his fingers. “In the dark. Where nobody could see. My mate thinks I’m going soft. The thing is, Miss Lowell, I don’t think it’s trying to hurt us. I think it wants something. I think it’s trying to say it. And I’ve a drill rig on this boat set to put twelve holes in the lake bed, and I have started to feel, God help me, like a man about to knock a hole in somebody’s front door.”
“Would you take us to the site?” I said. “Not to drill. Only to look.”
“I can do better,” said Fenn. “I’ve got the sonar.”
He turned in his chair and brought up the three screens, one after another. They were the side-scan survey, he said, run in July by the company’s advance vessel, before the permits were final. He had not looked at the Station Seven sector until the night before, when he could not sleep, and he had put it on the big monitor and sat looking at it until four in the morning.
It was a grey-green picture of the bed of the lake, in long soft stripes, like a ploughed field seen from a great height. At first it looked like any other sonar picture. Then Fenn pressed a key, and the picture steadied, and the colour changed, and I saw the shape.
It was a rectangle. Not a natural one. A flat-topped block, perhaps forty feet across, lying in the silt of the lake floor with a faint shadow along one side. On it, standing, was a second block, narrower, and across the top of that, a third. They formed a frame. A lintel and two posts.
“That’s not a wreck,” said Zara, in a voice that was nearly steady.
“No wreck’s that shape. I checked. There’s no hull on the chart for two hundred miles that’s a doorway.” He zoomed in. “And look at the lintel. The top beam. Here.”
The sonar had caught, on the face of the topmost block, a pattern of faint shallow grooves, caught in the light of the ping like the grain on a thumb. I leaned in. I saw a vertical stroke. A curved one, rising from its foot. A gap.
“It’s the mark,” I said. “It’s on the lintel. It’s forty feet high.”
“What I thought,” said Fenn. “I’ve been looking at it for two days. Your mark, and a doorway the size of a church, on the bottom of the lake, in the exact place my company’s planning to drill.” He sat back. “I could’ve ignored it. It’d be easy. The sonar tech who ran the scan did, and he’s not stupid, he just doesn’t like to know. But I’ve got a daughter, Miss Lowell. She’s twenty-two. She’s a vet. She told me something once when she was little, when a hamster of hers died. She said, ‘Dad, you’re only a coward if you look away *after* you’ve seen.’”
I put my hand on Biscuit, who was chattering in my pocket.
“Captain,” I said, and my voice was shaking, “that’s the best thing anybody’s said to me all week.”
“There’s one more thing,” said Fenn. He leaned across the table and brought the picture closer. “I’ve saved it for last. I don’t know if I’m seeing it. I’ve asked the second mate, and he says yes. I’ve asked the engineer, and he says no, but he went rather quiet.” He pressed a key. A small white square appeared on the screen, and then enlarged, and the grain of the image went soft.
In the doorway of the great stone frame, in the long grey light of the sonar, small and upright and very, very still, there stood a figure.
It was the height of a woman. It had its back to the lintel. One arm was raised. And at the end of that raised arm, spread flat against the stone, was a hand.

