The hunter lowered his weapon half an inch. He looked more annoyed than murderous, which was a distinction I hoped would continue to matter.
“Move,” he said.
“Tell me what happens when that jaw closes.”
“It disables the joint. Then I secure the body.”
“And then?”
“Then I sell the core.”
Behind him, the last of our people passed through the gate. Rhea stayed on the court side with me. Milo stood under the arch, reading something on the hunter’s white disk.
“The body just saved a person,” I said.
“It obstructed a hostile unit.”
“You don’t know why.”
“Neither do you.”
That was fair. I disliked hearing fair things from men who aimed metal jaws at decisions I hadn’t finished making.
The castoff stood between Rhea and the dead six-legged creature. Its left shoulder had split along the seam. Dark fibers hung loose, trembling whenever it moved. It kept its blade lowered. When Rhea shifted to go around it, the figure turned with her.
Guarding her, I thought.
Or keeping a useful obstacle close. We had an observation, not an answer.
“I’m Lennit Saye,” the hunter said. “Licensed recovery. I don’t need your permission to clear active discarded bodies from a public road.”
“We’re in a court.”
“You’ll want the road in a minute.”
Milo spoke quietly. “Dani. The disk has a claim radius. Twelve yards. He can’t mark it until it crosses the arch.”
Lennit gave him an irritated look. “Surveyor?”
“Yes.”
“Keep that habit and somebody will break your nose.”
“I’ve been advised to diversify.”
The jaw remained pointed at the castoff. Its cable, I noticed, ran through a guide along the weapon’s side and into a spool beneath Lennit’s right arm. The tool had captured stone earlier. He had needed both hands to pull it free. Effective at range. Less convenient if someone stood very close and made a bad decision.
I was becoming overqualified for that role.
I stepped in and put my knife against the guide cable.
Lennit went still.
“Cut that,” he said, “and you’re carrying every injured person on this road yourself.”
“What?”
“The same jaw catches wagons. Drags them out of gullies. It’s the only recovery line for eleven miles. You want to threaten something, understand it first.”
His voice had changed. Less contempt. More exhaustion.
I looked at the frayed patches on his sleeves and the careful repairs along the stock. The tool wasn’t disposable. Neither, probably, was his temper.
I moved the knife away.
“Then don’t make me choose between the tool and the thing that saved my friend.”
He studied me. “Fresh people always think the first body means something.”
“Maybe fresh people notice something you stopped checking.”
The castoff turned its face toward my voice.
For a second I felt the old certainty of being watched by an opponent across a practice strip. Then its head tilted. No attack followed.
Lennit lowered the weapon.
“Take it out the service side,” he said. “There’s a culvert under the west wall. A body that leaves with a recovery tag won’t trigger the road ward.”
“What tag?”
He unclipped a small brass plate from his belt and tossed it to me. The number on it rearranged into symbols the panel translated as pending assessment.
“You get one day,” he said. “I log it as damaged, uncollected. After that, somebody gets charged for the interference.”
“Who?”
“Probably the person stupid enough to listen.”
He stepped through the arch before I could decide whether to thank him. Outside, he addressed Patrice with immediate competence, pointing toward a low shelter beside the road. I heard him ask about water and ankle injuries. He could be useful and wrong about a castoff at the same time. My new world remained offensively complicated.
Rhea looked at the brass tag in my palm.
“You just volunteered us for a monster.”
“Possibly.”
“Be more accurate.”
“I volunteered myself. You should go with the group.”
“No. You don’t get to put that sentence on top of what actually happened.”
I shut my mouth.
She took a long breath. “We stayed. We can choose to keep staying. Tell us what you intend to do, and let us answer.”
“I intend to find out whether this thing can stop hunting me without being cut apart.”
Milo stepped out from the arch. “I want to know that too.”
Rhea watched the castoff. It remained in its defensive position, blade down, protecting her from a dead enemy.
“And if it can’t?” she asked.
“Then we don’t take it near people.”
“Good. That’s the line.”
We found the service culvert behind a stack of training shields. Milo scanned the entrance before we moved. No active units. The passage curved under the west wall, barely tall enough to walk bent over. Beyond it lay reeds, a dry drainage ditch, and a valley I couldn’t fit into the part of my brain responsible for geography.
The sky was pale amber. Tall ridges rose along both sides, their slopes covered in fragments of buildings. Towers without stairs. Stadium seating arranged around empty fields. A bell stood alone on a hill, larger than our whole gym. No visible hammer. Its mouth had been filled with white bodies stacked like kindling.
Farther down the valley, people had built a settlement beneath the stone ribs of an abandoned arena. Chimneys threaded smoke through the gaps. Gardens occupied the old spectator tiers. The road from our gate descended toward it.
“What happened here?” Rhea asked.
Milo read the closest broken wall. “Reclamation district. Active population four hundred and twelve.”
“That isn’t what I asked.”
“No,” he said. “It’s what it answered.”
The castoff wouldn’t enter the culvert.
I showed it the brass tag. Nothing. I stepped inside, then out. Its face followed me. When I moved closer, the right blade rose two inches.
Pursuit active, the panel warned. Temporary objective conflict unresolved.
It had saved Rhea. That didn’t make it harmless to me.
I backed away and let Rhea try. She pointed toward the passage. The figure looked at her hand, then stepped aside, allowing her to enter.
It followed her.
Milo and I exchanged a look.
“Don’t make it into a conclusion,” he said.
“I wasn’t.”
“You were making the face.”
“What face?”
“The one before you say something confidently.”
We followed at a distance.
Outside the culvert, the castoff caught its damaged shoulder on the stone. It stopped. Its right hand reached across to lift the left arm, lowering it carefully until the plate cleared the opening.
That was new behavior. No magical attack. No copied fencing stance. Just a body figuring out how to move while broken.
I wrote it down on the back of Lennit’s tag with the gym marker.
Milo watched me. “You could use paper.”
“I want the next assessor to notice it.”
The tag now said: cleared passage without attacking. Adjusted damaged arm. Saved Rhea from slat unit. Possible choice behavior; not established.
It was the least impressive manifesto in the history of moral philosophy. I was pleased with the final qualifier.
Rhea went to the road alone before we continued. The ward recognized her as a human participant and left her alone. That seemed obvious until I realized we were beginning to treat obvious things as rare gifts.
She returned with a packet of bandages, six strips of dried fruit, and news from Patrice. Forty-two of our people had reached the shelter. One late arrival from another branch had followed our written directions and joined them. The other gates remained active. Patrice would keep the list, cooperate with the road attendants, and find out what returning home required.
“Nobody wants us to bring the body to the shelter,” Rhea said. “I asked.”
“Fair.”
“They also asked whether you’re coming back.”
“What did you say?”
“That we’d try. I won’t give them a promise we can’t keep.”
I accepted the bandages. The shallow waist cut had soaked a small patch of my shirt. It needed cleaning. It didn’t need another discussion in which I tried to define which injuries counted as important.
Milo helped me wrap it while Rhea watched the castoff.
The practical problem was beginning to bite. Our food came from people we had left in another person’s care. Our water wouldn’t last a day. Saving the figure would cost time and resources that might have helped them instead. I couldn’t make that trade disappear by deciding I was morally interesting.
“We spend only what we can replace,” I said. “If a settlement takes us in, we work. No asking the evacuees to fund this.”
Milo tied the bandage, too tight at first, then loosened it. “Agreed. Also, we test before we trust. Restraint once could be a temporary conflict. Restraint twice gives us a better question.”
“And if it attacks somebody?” Rhea asked.
“We stop it.”
“Even if stopping it destroys it?”
I looked at the blank face. The body had my stance and none of my excuses. I couldn’t save the part I liked while ignoring the blade on its arm.
“Yes,” I said.
Rhea nodded. “Then I stay.”
Milo put the rest of the dried fruit in his bag, dividing it into three equal portions first. That small, careful action felt more like a commitment than a speech would have.
We walked down the ditch parallel to the road. The castoff followed Rhea, keeping me on its right side. Whenever I came within six feet, its blade lifted. When I retreated, it lowered again.
We had discovered a boundary. We respected it.
I tested the distance once more by rolling a stone across the line while I stayed still. The castoff watched the stone without raising its blade. When I moved one foot closer, the blade lifted.
“Target-specific,” Milo said. “Not a general personal-space response.”
Rhea marked the boundary with three pale pebbles. We could stop estimating it badly while tired. The castoff looked at the pebbles, then at my feet. It stepped backward, increasing the gap by another foot.
Neither of us had asked it to do that.
Milo added the observation to his notebook and kept the question mark.
My stamina recovered nothing while walking. I had four points, enough for two flicks or one veil with a spark. The shallow cut at my waist stung against the bandage Patrice had handed me before we parted. My ribs hurt when I twisted. The knee had moved from complaint to negotiation.
A flat place in the ditch let us sit without climbing back toward the warded road. Milo found a seep of clean-looking water and refused to call it safe without evidence. He scanned it twice. No detectable contamination. Unknown organisms. We drank our remaining bottled water instead and saved the problem for someone with a pot.
The castoff stood ten feet away.
“What do we call it?” Rhea asked.
“Castoff, for now.”
“That sounds like a judgment.”
“It’s the only term we have. I’m not naming it after a pet.”
Milo sat on a stone and opened his notebook. “Can it communicate?”
We tried simple things. Rhea held up one hand. The castoff looked at it. She lowered it, then pointed at the ground. No response. Milo tapped three times on the stone. The castoff turned toward the sound but didn’t repeat it.
I said my name. Its blade shifted.
“Useful,” I muttered. “I exist as a combat instruction.”
Then Rhea set the plywood shield down and moved away from it. The castoff looked at the shield, at her empty hand, and back at the shield.
It picked the shield up.
My skin prickled. The spear body hadn’t changed weapons. This one hadn’t been taught shield use. It held the handle awkwardly with its damaged arm, felt the strain, and transferred the shield to its right hand. The forearm blade scraped wood.
It put the shield down again.
“Inefficient attempt,” Milo said, writing quickly. “Recognized difficulty. Changed grip. Abandoned task.”
Rhea reached for the shield.
The castoff stepped on it.
Its head had turned toward the road.
I heard the clicking a moment later.
Three small white figures moved through the ditch farther uphill. Knee-high, narrow shoulders, long hooked fingers. They paused every few yards and pressed their hands to the soil. Their faces pointed in three different directions.
Lennit had called the road ward a protection. We weren’t on the road.
The nearest figure lifted its head.
Milo whispered, “Scavenger units. They track open core fibers.”
The castoff’s shoulder fluttered with loose dark strands.
“Well,” I said. “We brought snacks.”
Rhea raised the shield. The castoff stood beside her. I backed toward the seep, testing the mud with my good foot.
The scavengers came down the ditch at a run.
I flicked a coal at the first. The bead struck its smooth forehead, burst into sparks, and knocked it sideways. Two stamina left. The other two split around it, one climbing the bank, the other rushing straight at the exposed shoulder fibers.
The castoff tried to turn its damaged left shoulder away. The movement stalled halfway through. Its right blade shot across instead, too late for a clean interception.
Rhea caught the scavenger against the plywood shield.
The little body climbed the wood. Hooked fingers tore strips from the face. She thrust the shield away, tipping the creature into the mud, and stamped on its wrist before it could scramble up.
The flanking scavenger dropped from the bank toward my head.
I couldn’t Quickstep anymore. My body reached for the absent skill anyway.
For one instant I stood exactly where the creature expected.
Milo hit me with his shoulder. We went into the shallow seep together. The scavenger landed beside us, hooks sinking into wet soil.
I grabbed its wrist with both hands. No magic. It was stronger than I expected and lighter than it wanted to be.
“Mud,” I said.
Milo shoved its face into the water.
It thrashed. Rhea shouted something above us. The castoff struck the first scavenger hard enough to scatter white pieces against the bank. I held the submerged one’s wrist while Milo kept its head down.
The struggle stopped after ten seconds.
Neither of us let go immediately.
“Air intake,” Milo said, breathless. “It has a cooling intake under the face.”
I looked at the muddy water closing over the black openings. “That would have been useful before the wrestling.”
“I learned it during the wrestling.”
We hauled it out and moved away. It twitched once, then went still.
Rhea had pinned the remaining scavenger beneath the shield. The castoff raised its blade to finish it.
“Wait,” she said.
The blade stopped.
We all froze.
Rhea looked at me, then back at the figure. Her voice stayed level.
“Move back.”
The castoff didn’t move. Its blade trembled in the raised position. Fibers tightened along its neck. The trapped scavenger scraped at the shield’s underside.
Then the castoff stepped backward.
One pace. Its blade lowered.
Milo wrote nothing. His notebook had fallen in the seep. He simply watched.
I crouched far enough from the shield to stay clear of the hooks. The scavenger’s face was smooth, its motions repetitive. It pressed up, relaxed, pressed again. No hesitation. No change when Rhea spoke.
We had two different observations now.
I wasn’t ready to call one a person. I was no longer willing to call them identical.
A voice spoke from the bank above us.
“If you intend to learn by putting everything in a puddle, you’ll run out of puddles.”
A gray-haired woman stood beneath a patched cloth awning stretched across the ditch. She held a long pair of tongs and wore thick leather guards from wrist to elbow.
She pointed the tongs at the castoff’s shoulder.
“That one has about an hour before the loose fibers harden wrong,” she said. “Decide whether you’re saving it.”

