June Tolliver is waiting at her window with the lamp on, which tells me she has not been to bed since she left my shop.
Corbin brings the car around the corner of Lark Street at twenty-five past eleven with the headlamps off, because Rafe asked him to, and because Rafe asked me first whether I minded. I did not mind. Anton’s gray hats have been seen in four states this week, and a black sedan with its lights burning is a sentence anyone can read.
Mags rides in front, wrapped in a Dunmore blanket with her thimble on its string outside the wool. Rafe and Tam are in the back with me. Nobody has said anything since we left Sumner Street. Tam has the jug of tap water between his knees like a man carrying a baby across a river.
The shop lamp is still burning behind us. I left it on, and the radio, and the curtain half drawn over Mabel’s shoulder, so that Lowell at the street door will see a seamstress working late. Rafe suggested that, too. He put it as a question. I said yes, and he said “Thank you,” and I realized that I was waiting for the trick in it, and that there was none.
“Third floor,” I say. “Left. I’ll be two minutes.”
“I will come,” says Rafe.
“You’ll sit in the car and be a hat.”
“Noted,” he says, and I look at him, and the word is quite mild. He is smiling a little, at the window.
The door of the building opens before I reach it. June comes down the last three steps in her quilted coat, the color of a bruise at the second day, with a basket on her arm that has a clean tea towel folded over the top. Her hair is pinned. She has put on lipstick. I do not know why that is the thing that nearly undoes me.
“I packed it Tuesday,” she says, “and I unpacked it Wednesday, and I packed it again at nine tonight, because you’re not supposed to carry a thing that’s been sitting. Lavender goes on top. It’s Ruthie’s rule. You can smell if it’s been opened.”
“June.”
“The almanac is this year’s. I wrote nothing in it. Don’t let anyone tell you I wrote in it.” She lifts the towel an inch to show me, and the basket smells of a drawer in a good house: tea, soap, dry flowers. Honey in a jar with a cloth lid. Two linen handkerchiefs ironed into squares so sharp they could be cut with. “Tell her the soap’s the right one. She’s very particular. One year it was the wrong soap and I heard about it for a month.”
I stop with my hand on the basket handle. “Heard about it.”
“In the hollow. A slip of paper, in pencil. ‘Wrong soap, J.’” June’s mouth does something complicated. “Fifteen words, in twelve years, that weren’t thank you. I counted. I’m a bookkeeper.”
I take the basket. It weighs about what a toddler weighs. “I told you I’d carry it.”
“I know what you told me.” She puts her hand on my sleeve, her short hand with the scarred thumb. “I’m not coming down, and I’m not asking to. I only wanted to hand it to you. I’ve handed it to a hole in a wall for twelve years. I’d like to put it into a hand once.” She pats my wrist, twice, as she pats a column that has added up. “Go on. Mind your feet.”
She does not go back up. I look through the rear window as Corbin pulls away, and she is still standing on the step in the street light, with her hands folded in front of her coat like a woman at a bus stop who has seen the bus.
At the corner of Fell Street, Rafe clears his throat.
“May I say something that is not a plan?”
“If it isn’t a plan.”
“I would like to come down.” He is looking at his hat, not at me. “I know the answer. I should only like it to be recorded that I asked, and that I wanted to, and that I will not.”
“You’ll come to the freezer.”
“I will come to the freezer.” He turns the hat a quarter turn. “Somebody ought to stand at the top who has no business being at the bottom. My father stood at a great many tops.”
It is the first time he has said it without anger. I put my hand on the seat between us, not on his, and he looks at it, and he does not move his own, and that is the entire conversation.
Pell’s Diner has no roof, and so the sky has come inside.
I have been here once since the fire, with Mags, and it was a gray afternoon and the place looked like a stage after the play. At midnight it is different. The stars are in the rafters, black beams still standing from the wall plate to the ridge, with the night between them, and the cold comes down through the gaps and settles on the counter like a cat. Walter Lenz’s pumps have run on Sumner Street for three days and the cellar underneath has stopped breathing damp. The air smells of wet ash and old coffee and, very faintly, of meringue, which cannot be, and which I decide to allow.
There are eleven stools, bolted to the floor, with their red seats cracked and mended with tape. The black oak counter still runs the length of the place, and the pie case is a ghost of itself at the end with one cracked pane. The freezer door is at the back of the kitchen, past the swinging door that has no door in it now. The frost on its handle has thickened since Friday. I can see it from the front of the room, a patch of white in the dark, glittering faintly like a bridal veil in a sickroom.
Mags walks the length of the counter on Corbin’s arm, with her other hand flat under her ribs, and lets herself behind it by the little flap. She takes an apron off the hook where it has hung since the night of the fire. It is scorched at one corner. She ties it on over the Dunmore blanket and a hospital gown and stands there a moment with both hands on the black oak, as she must have stood a hundred thousand times.
“Pie case is gone,” she says. “Meringue is gone. I haven’t a single egg.” She pulls a lemon out of her apron pocket and sets it on the counter with a small, definite sound. “But I’ve got that.”
It is a good lemon, very yellow, a little soft.
“Twelve years,” she says, “every Thursday morning, hon. I buy it at the cart on the wharf, and I look at it, and I don’t cut it. I’ve got a chest freezer at my sister’s in Dunmore Heights with a hundred and some lemons in it, in a bread bag. She thinks I’ve lost my mind.” She nudges it toward the corner. “Tam, the water.”
Tam crosses the room on his toes, as if the floor might hear him, and pours the jug into a saucer she sets down. It is a plain white saucer, with a chip at the edge the shape of a thumbnail. The water is tap water, from the Drover Street standpipe. No ice. I look at it and a small laugh climbs into my chest and I put it down again, because nobody else has noticed. *A glass of tap water, no ice.* That was the order I carried through this diner, in a different week, in a different life. The door has been asking for water the whole time.
“Now,” says Mags. “The order. Don’t make a speech of it. You say it to the counter, you say it low, and you say it all the way to the end.”
I go to the middle of the counter and stand in front of a stool that has not been sat on since the spring. I put the basket down. I take a breath. I think of the stitch, of my own girl’s hand on the muslin, and I say it, in the voice I use for a bride who is crying.
“One lemon meringue. A side of lemon. And a saucer, not a glass, for the lady in the corner. Say it low.”
We wait.
The cold comes down through the roof. A bit of ash shifts somewhere and settles. The saucer holds a flat gray eye of water, and in it I can see a star, and a black beam, and my own face, small, with its mouth a little open.
Nothing happens.
“Lower,” says Mags. “Like you’re telling it to somebody asleep.”
I say it again, so softly that I can barely hear myself. A third time, on my breath. A fourth. By the fifth I am saying it to the saucer and to nobody, and my voice has gone ragged, and the freezer door stays what it has always been when the order is wrong, which is a freezer door at the back of a burned kitchen. The frost is the only thing shining on it.
“It’s twelve past,” says Tam.
“It’s eleven fifty-three,” says Rafe, who has a watch. “Tam, you are early. Nell, may I?”
“May you what?”
“Think aloud. Not about the words.” He is standing at the end of the counter with his coat still buttoned, and I understand that I have been looking at the wrong half of the problem, because he has been looking at the right one. “You have said it five times. Mrs. Pell has said it was never wrong when your mother said it. Your mother said it, I assume, in a particular place.”
I look at Mags.
“She sat,” says Mags slowly. “She always sat.”
“Where?”
Mags does not answer. She is looking down the counter, to the far end, where the black oak turns the corner into the wall and the last stool stands with its back to the pie case. It is the eleventh. The red seat is not mended with tape. It is worn through the vinyl to the gray cotton underneath, in a long soft shape, like a thumbprint in dough. I have been looking at it for ten minutes and I have taken it for the broken one.
“Hon,” says Mags, and her voice is not steady. “I have put a glass in front of that stool every Thursday of my life and never once asked myself why nobody sat there.”
I take the saucer. I carry it the length of the room, level, with both hands, past ten stools. I put it on the counter at the corner and then I put the lemon beside it, and then, because I am a person who cannot help herself, I take my foot out of its shoe and slip it onto the footrest. The chrome bar has a dip in it. A long, shallow dip, polished bright, the width of a small shoe. It is a good deal smaller than my foot. I put it there anyway, and the bar is cold through my stocking, and I sit down on the stool my mother sat on.
The seat gives under me in the shape of her.
I do not say a word for a long moment. Nobody does. Then I put my hand flat on the counter, beside the saucer, with my thimble turned toward the room.
“One lemon meringue,” I say. “A side of lemon. And a saucer, not a glass, for the lady in the corner.” I do not whisper it. I find that I do not need to. It comes out of me at the pitch I used at six years old to tell her I was awake. “Say it low.”
“Coming up,” says Mags Pell, and her voice breaks in the middle of it.
The freezer door sighs.
It is not loud. It is the sound of a very big thing letting go of something it has held for a long time. The frost on the handle cracks like sugar. The needle of the thermometer, pinned past the end of its scale for as long as I have known the door, drops, shivering, and swings across the dial to a number I cannot read. A smell reaches us along the length of the kitchen, and it is not cold. It is wet stone and old lamp oil, and under that, so faint that I think I have made it up, the smell of lavender.
“Oh,” says Mags. She has sat down, abruptly, on the step stool behind the counter. “Oh, Ruthie.”
The door is already open when we reach it, a hand’s width, and a lamp is burning inside.
I did not expect a lamp. It is a plain brass ship’s lantern, hung from a hook on the back wall of the freezer, which is bare to the metal, and lit, low, so low that the flame is the size of a pea. The shelves have been swung aside on a hinge I never saw. Behind them is a stair, going down. It is narrow and steep, and cut into brick, with a rope rail on the left, and the first step is dry.
Rafe stops at the threshold. He does it deliberately, one foot on the kitchen tile and one on the lip of the frozen floor, with the door held against his shoulder.
“I will be here,” he says.
“If anyone comes—“
“Corbin is at the front, Mrs. Pell is at the counter, and I am a man standing in a doorway. They have all had a great deal of practice.” He looks at the lantern, and at the stair, and then at me, and I see him decide to say it plainly. “Come back up, Nell. That is the whole of my request. I have other requests, and I am setting them down.”
“Forty minutes,” says Mags, behind us. She has got up again and come as far as the door of the kitchen, leaning on Corbin. “It’s slack water at midnight for forty minutes, and then the tide turns and the door goes back to being a door until next Thursday. I never knew what was on the other side of it, hon. I only ever knew the clock.”
“Next Thursday.”
“Whoever’s down there when it shuts is down there a week.”
Tam is at my elbow with the basket on one arm and the saucer on the other, held in both hands at the level of his belt, the water in it flat as a plate. He is taking his shoes off. He puts them side by side on the kitchen tile with the socks inside. Tam’s sister is eight days dead and he has not whistled since the funeral, and I watch his bare feet go onto the first step of a stair that smells of lamp oil and I think: *Whatever I am doing, I am not doing it alone.*
“I’m in the book,” he says. “Row one. I looked.” He glances at me sideways. “Don’t tell me what it says.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
“Good.” He swallows. “I’ll go first. If it’s wet I’ll know.”
We go down. Rafe’s hand comes off the door, and the freezer door begins, very slowly, to swing toward its frame, and he catches it on his forearm and stands there holding it with the whole weight of the world on his sleeve.
“Nell,” he says.
I look up.
“I am not angry,” says Rafe. “I would like you to know I am using the contractions I do not have.”
“You aren’t using any.”
“No,” he says. “That is the difficulty.” And then there are stairs, and the brick closing in on both sides, and the lantern swinging above me on its hook, and his voice, from the top, saying a thing I do not hear. I count steps because it is what I do. Nine. Eleven. Eighteen. The rope under my hand is waxed linen, new, and every ninth loop of it has been left dropped.
I stop.
It is not rope. It is a cord, a heavy waxed cord worked in chain stitch, thick as my thumb. Someone has stitched it, loop on loop, the way my mother taught me to make a hem weight bag on a Sunday afternoon, a stitch that unravels all in a single pull if you know where the end is. It runs down the left wall of the stair, fixed at every yard in iron staples, and it goes down, as far as the light goes, and farther.
I know the stitch. I know the dropped link. I have been taking in a quarter inch on strangers’ shoulders for twelve years with that dropped link in my own hands, and I have never seen it done on this scale.
“Nell,” says Tam, from below. “There’s a landing.”
It is a small square landing, eighteen feet below the freezer, with a brick floor and a low arched roof. There is a bracket on the wall at the height of my hip, a shelf of black iron the size of a cake plate with a round dip in it, and Tam sets the saucer in it and lets go, and the water trembles, and stills, and it is very odd how hard we both watch it.
On the floor beside the bracket, side by side against the wall, is a pair of boots.
They are ladies’ rubber boots, black, with white soles worn gray, laced to the ankle and waxed until they shine under the lamp. A tag is tied to the left one with a bit of yellow tape, burned at the end, and I know the tape, and the pencil, and the way the t is crossed, toward the writer. I pick up the tag, and the lantern light slides across it.
*Penelope, 7½.*
I sit down on the bottom step and I take off my shoes.
Nobody has told me that your mother can leave you something and have it be the wrong size. They are half a size too small. They were bought for a girl of seventeen with a narrow foot, in the winter before the last winter, and set down at the foot of a stair in the dark to wait for her, and waxed again every Thursday by somebody’s careful hands until the day the hands stopped. The wax is pliable. The laces are new. She has been replacing the laces.
I get my foot into the left boot, with my toes curled, and I stand up in it, and it hurts. It hurts exactly enough that I know it is real.
There is a second line on the tag, under the first, in the same pencil, smaller, and as I turn it to the light I understand that it was written last, in a different week, with a different pen.
*Slack water gives you forty minutes. Do not be gracious. R.*
Tam is looking at me. He has the lantern off its hook and the basket in the crook of his arm.
“Is it her?” he says.
I put the other boot on. I tie the laces. I tie them twice, in the double knot she taught me when I was four, and then I stand up in my mother’s boots on a brick landing under the sluice floor, with the stair going on down into the dark, and the cord of her stitching under my hand, and the saucer shivering in its bracket at my hip.
“It’s her hand,” I say. “It’s not mine to say yet whether it’s her.”
“You’ve got that look.”
“What look?”
“The one you get when you’ve found the hem allowance and it’s been let out.” He tries to smile. “Somebody’s been here.”
“Somebody’s been waiting,” I say, and I start down.

