Nolan Pierce arrives on Day 23 in a rented SUV, wearing disposable blue booties over his loafers like a man visiting a hospital for goats.
On my scale he’s a half goat: all fleece, no animal. He has a vest, a lawyer, a smile that was clearly installed, and a cashier’s check in a leather folder, which he lays on the hood of the SUV as if he were setting a table. The lawyer is a gray man named Sedgwick who looks at the mud as if it owes him money.
“Chief,” Nolan says to Anders. He claps him on the shoulder. “You look great. Farm life.”
“Nolan.”
“Ms. Bell. Josie, may I?” He doesn’t wait. “I want you to know the team has nothing but respect for what you’ve built here.”
“The team.” I keep my arms crossed. “Which one?”
“Six point four million.” He slides the folder toward me. “Cash at closing, a hiring commitment for the whole town, and a heritage herd experience on site. Your goats would live right beside the facility. Visitors could pet them.”
“Beside the cooling towers.”
“Beside the cooling towers.”
I look at the check. It’s a lot of zeros. It would pay the note more than a hundred times and buy every goat in Vermont a hat. For eleven seconds, I admit it, I look at it the way you look at a lit window from outside in the cold.
Then Pearl comes down off the porch with her cane, and Nolan turns his smile on her and speaks in a very loud, very slow voice. “Mrs. Bell! What a charming place.”
“I’m old, Mr. Pierce, not deaf,” says Pearl. “The deaf one is Moses, and he’s a good deal more fun.” She puts out her hand. Nolan shakes it, and afterward I see him wipe his palm on his handkerchief, quick, the way you wipe off a doorknob.
Pearl sees it, too. “Goat soap,” she says pleasantly. “Scrubbed it myself.”
Dewey’s flatbed pulls in at ten sharp for his Tuesday delivery and stops fifty feet short, which isn’t like him. He climbs down and walks over with a hand out. “Dewey Marchand. Selectboard.”
“Nolan Pierce.”
“Never had the pleasure.”
“Likewise.”
They shake. That’s all it is. But Dewey doesn’t whistle once the whole time Nolan is here, and I notice it the way you notice a clock stopping.
Nolan, meanwhile, closes the folder and gets to the point, like every man who thinks he’s been patient. “I’ll be plain, Ms. Bell. Your balloon payment is due on the fifteenth. We both know what a bank does with a deadline.”
The yard goes quiet. Somewhere, a hen puts her entire opinion into one syllable.
Nobody knows about the note. Pearl doesn’t. Moses doesn’t. Anders promised, and I believed him, which leaves a short list: the bank, the dossier, and whoever fed it.
Anders has gone white around the mouth. “Nolan. A word.”
“We’re just team-building—”
“A word.”
They walk to the far end of the yard, beside the manure pile, which is the only honest place on this farm for a conversation like that. I can’t hear them. I watch Nolan’s hand open and close twice. Then he gets in the SUV and leaves with his lawyer, his check, and his booties, and Anders walks back to me looking like he’s been punched.
“Respectfully, no,” I tell the dust where the SUV was.
“I told him that’s the last time he talks about the note.” Anders rubs his jaw. “He said he’s sorry.”
“Is he?”
“No.”
That night he comes down from the Bar after his phone hour and goes straight to the milk house, and I ask him, because we have a deal, if Delphine found anything.
“She’s still digging,” he says, to the bucket in his hands, not to me.
I believe him. I just don’t believe that’s all of it. I know the difference, because I’ve been telling that kind of truth for eight years. I decide he’s tired and let it go, which is the kind of decision that looks worse later, in a different light.
The sugar-on-snow supper is on Saturday night, Day 27, at the fire hall.
If you’ve never been to one, here’s the science. You boil maple syrup until it’s hot enough to go chewy, pour it in ribbons across a pan of packed snow, and it turns into the best taffy you’ve ever had in your life. You eat it with a plain doughnut and a sour pickle, because sugar needs an enemy.
A fiddle and an accordion play in the corner. The long tables are covered in paper. The whole town comes, and the whole town talks, and this year the talk has a tall man in the middle of it.
“Heard you fixed Moses’s gate,” says Mrs. Larrabee, and gives Anders a pickle like a medal.
“Does he know it’s fixed?”
“He’s heard,” says Moses, loud, from three seats down, having switched his ear on for a doughnut. “Goat likes him. We’re considering it.”
Senator Bernard is allowed in. Pearl crocheted him a bow tie. He eats three paper plates and a program, and he has never looked happier.
I’m at the end of a table, licking taffy off my thumb and trying not to look at a man looking at me, when the fiddle slides into something slow.
“Can I ask a question?” Anders says, appearing beside my chair.
“No.”
“Fair.”
I put down my taffy. “Ask.”
“Would you dance with me?”
“I get paid in cheese. I don’t dance.”
“Neither do I.” He holds out his hand. “I’m told that’s the best way.”
I take it, because it’s a stupid idea, and because the whole fire hall has stopped pretending not to watch. We turn on the linoleum between the pickle trays, badly, his hand warm on my back, and somebody whoops, and a child asks loudly if that’s the billionaire. At the long table by the door, Pearl is passing a five-dollar bill to Connie Duquette, folded very small, with great dignity.
“They bet?” I say into his shirt.
“I believe it’s the first thing the Committee has agreed on all month.”
Dewey whistles at me from the pie table, a different tune this time, a cheerful one, and calls, “About time, kiddo.” I wave. I’m so happy that it takes a while to notice I’ve forgotten to check my pocket for the twist tie I’ve been carrying for twenty-three days.
We walk home under the biggest, coldest, brightest sky of the season, past the dark farms and the mud shining like pewter, with Bernard clip-clopping behind us in a bow tie. At the milk house door, he stops.
“Josie. Section nine—”
“Is about gifts.”
“I’m aware.”
“I’m not giving you a gift.” I take his hand. “I’m giving you a chance. It’s worth a lot less than twenty-five dollars.”
Bernard looks at us, looks at the sky, and lies down across the threshold like a chaperone with ears, with the expression of a goat who has been informed that the rest is private.
It is.
I wake at 5:12 because Bernard is screaming.
It’s not the breakfast scream. It’s the other one, high and cracked, which I have heard exactly twice in my life. I’m down the bunk room stairs with a coat over nothing much and Anders on my heels, and the cold air hits us across the yard.
The door to the cave is standing wide open, propped with a milk crate.
The air that comes out to meet me is warm.
My father had one rule about that cave. Don’t leave the door open.

