There’s nothing to do while the lab thinks, so I make cheese angrily.
It’s Monday, 4:40 a.m., and the make room is full of steam and the sound of me stirring a vat of Chevre like it owes me money. Chevre is fresh, no aging, the one cheese I make from pasteurized milk because the law says so and my father, who held no other opinion about the law, let that one go. It’s the only cheese on this farm that forgives you. Which is why I’m furious at it.
“You’re going to cut the curd to powder,” Pearl says from the doorway.
I look down. She’s right. I put the paddle down.
My grandmother comes in, in her quilted robe and her goat-ear hat, and she puts a slip of paper on the steel table next to the molds. It’s the back of a crochet pattern. There’s a phone number on it in her small hand, with a Florida area code.
“I didn’t ask for that.”
“No,” Pearl says. “You’ve been asking for it for three days without opening your mouth.”
“How long have you been talking to her?”
I didn’t plan to say it. It comes out sideways, like a goat through a gap in the fence.
Pearl doesn’t pretend. That’s the thing about her: she’ll manipulate you by calendar for six weeks, but if you ask her a straight question at 4:40 in the morning, she answers it. “Every Christmas, the day after the postcard. She calls the twenty-sixth, around four. I say hello. We talk about the weather.” She folds her hands. “Last December she asked me to sell my half. To someone kind, she said. I told her no.”
“That’s what you meant. At the vote. ’I told you no.’”
“That’s what I meant.”
“You never said.”
“You never asked.” She picks up the paddle, and her hand shakes slightly, and she puts it down. “Josephine, I have made a great many mistakes with the calendar. This one wasn’t mine to make. Whether you ring her is yours.”
She leaves me with the curd and the slip of paper. I put the paper in my pocket, and I scald the next batch, which is the first one I’ve lost since Christmas.
At dusk, I walk to the Bar.
I haven’t used the one hour of phone in weeks. I climb up on the boulder with my back to the wind and hold the phone above my head like a woman offering it to a god. One bar. I dial Florida.
It rings five times. Then a recording comes on in a voice I know and don’t know. It’s pleasant, and unhurried, and it says, “You’ve reached Lorraine Bell. I’m away from my desk. Leave me a message and I’ll call you right back.”
The tone beeps. I stand on a boulder in the dark with a thousand things to say.
“Stop calling my grandmother,” I say, and hang up.
That’s four words. Anders is waiting at the bottom of the pasture with a flashlight and a goat, and he says nothing about it, which is one of the nicest things anyone has ever done.
On Tuesday, no feed truck comes.
It’s the first Tuesday since 1998. Ten o’clock comes and goes, and the lane is quiet, and I find myself listening for a four-note whistle that isn’t there. Marchand Feed & Hardware has a paper sign taped inside the door, CLOSED UNTIL FURTHER NOTICE, in a hand I know. I order from a supplier in St. Johnsbury. The new driver is polite, and in a hurry, and the bags are tied with plain white string.
I notice I’m checking for green twist ties. I notice I’m sorry about it. I hate both things.
The lab sends its results to Odom on Wednesday at 10:15, and she drives them out herself, because she doesn’t trust screens either.
She arrives with a manila folder, a coffee, and a paper bag from the Notch Store. We stand in the cave, because apparently that’s where the verdicts happen. I watch her read the first page and then the second page and then give a small, flat nod.
“Drain’s clean,” she says. “Shelves clean. Door handle’s cleaner than my kitchen.” She turns a page. “Brine tubs, clean. Floor, clean.”
I don’t realize I’m holding on to a rack until my knuckles complain.
“It’s a good scrub, Ms. Bell. You and the whole town.” She closes the folder. “Here’s the legal part. Raw milk, sixty-day minimum. Anything aging in that cave that’s not at sixty days by the time it leaves is a violation, and I’m going to inspect it that way. Your seventy-one wheels are over sixty days, all of them. Your Chevre’s pasteurized, which is the law. So the first box is fine. And I’ll tell you now: I’ll be counting days on every wheel after that.”
“I know the rule.”
“I know you know it. I’m saying it so you can’t say I didn’t.” She sets the paper bag on the shelf. “Also. Bound log.”
She takes it out of the bag. It’s a plain black ledger with numbered pages, hardcover, sewn binding, impossible to tear a page out of without somebody noticing. There’s a price sticker on the back. $11.00.
“Section nine,” I say.
“Section nine is for applicants. I’m the state.” She almost smiles. “I looked it up anyway. I was in the Notch Store for the doughnuts. Mrs. Larrabee told me what the limit is. Eleven dollars is under twenty-five.”
“Is it a gift?”
“It’s a deficiency correction,” says Phyllis Odom, which is the nicest thing she has ever said to me. “Use it.”
By noon the whole farm knows. Mrs. Larrabee brings a pie, which I accept because I’ve learned. Pearl hums while she crochets. In the make room, Anders turns out, to everyone’s surprise, to be remarkable at cutting wedges: he scores each quarter wheel with a wire, even and square, with his tongue in the corner of his mouth, like a man doing a tax return he’s proud of.
“You cut like you negotiate,” I say. “Even. And everything is somehow in your favor.”
“I prefer to think of it as fair.”
“Same thing.”
He grins, a real one, with teeth, and I hold on to it for a moment before I’m interrupted.
The mail carrier’s name is Bev Cote, and she’s driven this route for thirty years. She comes up the lane at two in a little white truck, which is early, and stops at the porch instead of the box. This is how I know it’s bad.
“Certified,” says Bev, in the voice of a woman who would rather be handing me a sandwich. “I need a signature, Josie.”
The envelope is cream and heavy. The return address says SEDGWICK & HALE LLP, BURLINGTON. I sign Bev’s little screen with my finger, and she touches my arm, once, and leaves.
I open it on the porch. Anders reads it over my shoulder, because I tilt it.
Notice of Termination of Permissive Use. Birchwater Land Partners LLC, owner of the parcel known as the Tuttle strip, hereby gives notice that any license, tolerance or permission previously extended to the owners of Bell Hollow Farm to cross said parcel is terminated, effective 12:01 a.m., Saturday, May 16. This notice is given at the direction of the sole member of record, L. A. Bell.
I read it twice, and then I read the map, which is stapled on the back.
The strip is sixty feet wide. It runs across the middle of my farm like a belt, between the home pasture and the north rise, and on either side of it the ledge drops to the brook. There’s one lane across it, the lane Walt Bell drove with a tractor in 1971 and Ray drove with a truck and I drive now. Everything north of that lane is behind the north gate: the sugarhouse, the north pasture, the Bar, the Spring, and my father and grandfather under their maple.
Without the road, none of it can be reached. Not by goat, not by truck, not by me.
“May sixteenth,” says Anders quietly.
It’s Share Day. It’s the day two hundred and thirteen households are coming up my road to get their cheese.
And my mother has decided it is the day they won’t be able to.

