"You're humming," said Marcus.
"I'm not."
"You're humming. It's very faint. It's a sort of waltz." He sat on the library ladder with an orange, peeling it in one long unbroken spiral, a trick he had apparently taught himself at the age of nine to annoy the cook. "You've been humming since breakfast. You hummed through the eggs. You hummed in front of Ambrose, who gave you a look."
"I did not hum in front of Ambrose."
"He put an extra scone on your plate."
"That's not the same as being looked at."
"With Ambrose, an extra scone is a sonnet." Marcus popped a segment into his mouth and chewed with enormous satisfaction. "I'm happy for you. I want that on the record. I'm also terrified of my cousin, so I will never say it again."
Dess bent over the bench so he would not see her face.
It was morning, Day 19, and the Cabinet Room smelled of cold ashes and old paper and a faint, warm thread of coffee. The Table's oak slab had been carried back out. In its place stood a long folding trestle, covered in butcher paper, and on the butcher paper, in Pip's furious capitals and Dess's neat blue pen, a chart that was beginning to look like a conspiracy.
It had two columns.
At the head of the left-hand column Pip had written, in red marker, HAND A (LEFT-HANDED / DIMPLE). At the head of the right, HAND B (RIGHT-HANDED / DEEP STAMP).
"Okay," said Pip. She stood on a stepladder with a marker in each hand and a pencil in her hair. "Sixty-one fakes. I've been up since four. I made a spreadsheet, and then I made a different spreadsheet, and then I drew it on paper because I wanted to feel something."
"And?"
"And look." She slapped the sheet. "I sorted them by tell. Dimple versus hallmark. Thirty-eight have the dimple. Twenty-three have the deep stamp. No lot has both. And the minute I separated them, they stopped being a pile and started being two crimes."
Dess walked along the paper with her finger.
"Thirty-eight with the dimple," she said slowly. "Teddy's been sent eleven real lots in fourteen months. Six of her real lots match six dimple fakes. The others..."
"The others are the next batch. We haven't found them yet." Pip bounced on the ladder. "Here's the thing. The dimple fakes, every single one, has a Condition Card signed in your father's hand. The ink's recent. The pressure's right. You said so yourself. The hand's authentic."
"It's him."
"It's him. The same day he swaps a lot, he signs a card. A beautiful, honest, genuine card. Which says: this object is in original condition." Pip's eyes were bright. "Which is a lie. But it's a very polite lie."
"Why would he sign a lie?"
"I don't know yet. But look at the other column." She tapped it. "Twenty-three deep-stamp fakes. The cards under them are also signed 'R. Whitlock.' But the pen pressure's wrong. The loop on the R is too round. The ink was aged with something. Tea, I think. It fluoresces yellow under UV."
"Real ink doesn't."
"Real ink is gray-green." Pip jumped down. "Dess. Someone is forging his signature on top of his signature. And they're better at it than anyone I've ever seen, and they're still not him. And I think they know it. I think they want people to think it's him."
Dess stared at the chart.
Two columns. Two hands. Two crimes, one pattern.
It came to her in a rush, so clean and cold and obvious that she wondered how she had missed it.
"Hand A swaps a real lot for a fake. And ships the real one to safety." She said it slowly. "He puts the real one in a flat file in a carriage house. In a locked drawer. Somewhere nobody would look. He's not stealing. He's hiding."
"Protecting," said Pip.
"Protecting. From what?"
"From Hand B."
"Hand B swaps a real lot for a fake. And sells the real one." She turned from the paper. Her pulse was going. "Hand B takes the Pruitt watch. Hand B sells the fake to Leopold for six million dollars. Hand B takes the lots that matter, and signs my father's name on everything, so that when this all comes apart, it comes apart on a dead man."
"Or a live one," said Marcus quietly, from the ladder.
"Or a live one."
"So there's two forgers in my house," said Marcus. "One's a thief and one's a bodyguard."
"A very odd bodyguard," said Dess.
"And only one of them's your dad."
"Yes."
"Okay." He set down the orange. "Which means the other one's here. In the house. Or someone with a key."
Nobody spoke.
The clock in the corridor struck ten.
The double doors opened, and Elias came in with a folder under his arm and his tie slightly crooked. He looked at the butcher paper, at Pip on her ladder, at Marcus with an orange peel hanging from one finger. Then at Dess.
It was a small, quick, unguarded look. It lasted perhaps a second. It was the look of a man who had spent the night thinking of one particular thing, and had just found it in a room.
"Good morning," he said, very formally.
"Good morning."
"You've made a chart."
"Pip made a chart. I'm only the pen."
"It's a very good chart." He came to stand beside her, an inch closer than he needed to, and studied the two columns in silence. She was aware of everything about him: the faint scent of cedar, the heat of his shoulder through two layers of wool, the small, steady, disciplined way he did not touch her. Pip, on her ladder, made an elaborate show of examining the ceiling.
"Hand A protects," said Elias at last, slowly. "Hand B steals."
"That's our theory."
"And the man who's protecting is the one my father kept alive."
"Yes."
"Then my father's been running a very quiet war against his own household for fourteen months." He rubbed his jaw. "I'd like to be angry. It's a remarkably efficient plan."
"It's a family tradition," said Marcus, mouth full.
"I'm going to have the doors changed," Elias said. "Today. New locks on the Cabinet. Nobody has a key but me."
"And Cordelia?"
"She'll want one."
"Will you give it to her?"
He was silent for a long moment. "No," he said.
It sat in the room like a stone dropped in a well. Nobody asked what it cost him.
He left a few minutes later for the Blue Room, where a locksmith was waiting and a doctor was changing a dressing, and the door clicked shut behind him with a care that was almost tender.
Dess took a deep breath and went back to her own work, the real work, the unglamorous endless slow work of the Hundred. Nineteen days gone, eighty-one to go. A hundred and sixty-eight lots examined, and forty-four of them certified. A long way to two hundred. She sat at the baize table with Marcus beside her and lifted a small ivory fan out of Drawer 119, and set it down under the lamp.
She froze.
She had certified Lot 119 last week. She remembered it exactly. It was an ivory brisé fan, Chinese export, circa 1840, with a faint crack on the third leaf and a tiny silver pin through the guard. She had spent forty minutes with it. She had written her name on its Condition Card. She had pressed her own wax seal into the fold of the Letter, with Marcus sitting on the ladder with an orange, watching.
She held the fan up to the lamp.
The ivory was wrong.
It was beautiful. It was right in every way that mattered to a glance. But there was a faint cast to it, a yellow blush, like the film on old milk. She tilted it. She put on her gloves. She took out the loupe, the brass one, the one that might be an heirloom or a copy, and held it over the third leaf.
The crack was too smooth. It had been cut, not grown. The silver pin was drilled instead of cast. And on the underside of the guard, in the shadow where no one ever looked, there was a hallmark: a tiny, crisp, correct, slightly-too-deep stamp.
"Marcus," she said.
"Hm?"
"Come here."
He came. She put the fan in his gloved hands and the loupe in his fingers and said, very quietly, "Look at the hallmark."
He looked. She watched his face go still.
"That's deep," he said.
"Yes."
"That's the other one's."
"Yes."
"But you certified this." His voice cracked. "I watched you. That day. You sat right there. You sealed it. You wrote your name on the card."
"I know."
"It was real."
"It was real. I'd put my life on it." She could hear herself breathing. "Marcus. The card under it is in my handwriting. My signature. My date." She drew it out of the drawer and held it up with a hand that would not stay steady. "I didn't write this."
It was a perfect copy.
It was her loop on the D. Her small impatient slash on the T. The way she always, always dotted the i with a little downward flick, a habit from a third-grade teacher in Worcester. It was her hand, to the pressure, to the pause, to the very faint ink blot where she'd lifted the pen.
It said: LOT 119. Examined and certified in original condition. O. Whitlock. And the date of that day, with a wax seal in the fold, her seal, the Registry's, pressed with a firm, careful, even hand.
Someone had broken her seal. Someone had made a fan. Someone had made a card, in her handwriting, and laid it in the drawer under her own eyes, in the week since she had sealed it.
"It's not possible," said Marcus. His face was white. "I've been in this room for every single lot. I sat right there. I didn't leave. I took a leak twice and I locked the doors."
"I know you did."
"Dess. I swear to God."
"I know." She laid her hand on his arm. "I believe you."
"Then how?"
"I don't know." She looked at the card. The little downward flick on the i. "But someone in this house has my handwriting. And a fan. And a key to a drawer I locked myself."
Behind her, very softly, in the corridor, a floorboard creaked.
She turned. The double doors stood open a hand's width. In the gap, in the dim gray light of the hallway, stood Mr. Ambrose, with a tea tray. His face was perfectly composed. His hands were perfectly steady. And behind him, in the shadow of the stairs, a tall, thin woman in gray was drawing back out of sight, with the slow, unhurried grace of someone who has stood in a doorway for some time.

