Skip to content
Zodygo
Clean Ice

Chapter 29

Eleven Fifty-Two

I pressed play, and my father cleared his throat.

It's the thing I remember. Before the words, before the stairwell echo and the tinny hiss of an old phone mic, a small dry sound, the cough of a man who is about to say something he's practiced. I had heard it across a thousand kitchen tables. I had forgotten it existed.

"Mar." The voice was a little breathless, a little hoarse, close to the microphone. "It's Dad. I know you won't pick up. That's all right. I called twice and I understand."

Beside me Cal sat perfectly still. The only light in the truck was the glow of the phone, a small blue square on my knee. Outside, the east lot had emptied. The game had ended hours ago. Somewhere beyond the windshield a janitor was turning off the lights, row by row.

"I'm in the east stairs, after the game. It's quiet here. I wanted to get this down while I've still got my nerve." A pause. Footsteps, slow, somewhere below him. A faint metal clang, a door far off. "I'll say the small things first. The notebook's under Ruth's seat. The calendar's on the wall. The key is in my jacket, and I've told your grandmother. If anything happens, ask Hollis Pike. He'll know."

I put my fist against my mouth.

"Now the big one." His breath caught. "Marnie, I did something to you. Ten years ago. I told Cal Dorsey you'd taken a job in Chicago and that he'd be holding you back. It wasn't true. You hadn't been offered anything. I made it up in the parking lot, in the rain, like a man telling a story to a child."

I heard a small sound beside me, a tight, strangled exhale. Cal had gone rigid.

"I thought I was protecting you. I told myself that. I thought he'd take you away from here, and you'd be a stranger in a city, and I'd be alone in a rink with a cat." His voice cracked. "Mar, I was afraid of an empty building. That's the truth. That's all it was. I kept two kids apart for ten years because I was afraid to be left. And I never told either of you. I let you both think the other one walked away."

He was crying. I'd never heard it. Not at my mother's funeral, not at the hospital, not when I left for Chicago with a duffel and a grudge. It was a quiet sound, almost embarrassed, the sound of a big man trying not to be a nuisance.

"I'm sorry," he said. "That's the biggest one. I'm so sorry. You'd have been fine. You'd have been better than fine. I called him in March. I think he'll come. Be kind to him. He was a good kid. He's a good man."

Cal made a sound I will never forget, and put both hands over his face.

"The rest," said my father, and his voice steadied, the way a skater finds an edge. "The rest is quick. The ice is being run by somebody else. Preston Vail works for the people who own Meridian. They're using it to move betting lines. They did it to Cal, in Cold Harbor. They'll do it to us. I'm taking it to Okafor on Monday, and I'm taking Lew with me, if he'll come. I'd rather not do it alone."

A noise behind him, a scuff of shoes on concrete. He didn't seem to hear.

"I love you more than the ice," said my father, and laughed through the tears, a small wet laugh. "I know. That's a hell of a thing for me to say. I love you more than anything I ever built. You are the best thing I made, and I didn't make you, your mother did. Tell Babcia the pierogi dough was always better than mine. Tell Lew..."

A pause. Footsteps. Closer.

"Tell Lew I..."

"Gene."

It was a new voice. It was low, flat, quiet, almost gentle, just outside the range of the microphone, as if the speaker had stepped out of the dark. It spoke the way you speak to a horse that might bolt.

"Off the stairs, Gene."

The recording ran for another four seconds. There was a rustle. A breath. My father said, in a voice I had never heard him use, very small and very surprised, "Oh. It's you."

Then a thump, and a long, long clatter, and a click.

The phone went silent.

For a long time nobody moved.

"Play it again," I said.

"Mar..."

"Play it again."

He took the phone out of my hand, gently, as though it might hurt me, and thumbed the screen. We listened a second time. And a third. Each time I listened for the other voice and each time it slid away from me like a fish. A man's, I thought. Then a woman's. Then neither. It had no accent, no age, no particular weight. It was a voice you could pass in a hallway and not remember.

"It's not Vail," Cal said, very low.

"No."

"Vail's voice has more...music. And Pete said Vail left him alive."

"He did." I pressed the heels of my hands into my eyes. "Pete said he was breathing when Vail left. Someone else came after."

"Someone he knew."

"Oh. It's you," I whispered. "He knew who it was."

"Marnie."

"He knew them. He was surprised. He wasn't afraid, he was just..." I couldn't finish.

Cal put an arm around my shoulders and pulled me against him, and I let myself fall. I cried the way I hadn't cried in eight months, loudly, wetly, ugly, into the front of his warm-up jacket. I cried for the man in the stairwell. I cried for the call I hadn't taken. I cried for ten years, and for the lie, and for the tiny, impossible grace of a phone that had waited in a sock drawer until I could bear it.

He held me. He didn't say anything. After a while I felt his shoulders shaking too.

On Sunday morning I took the phone to Okafor. He listened to it in the conference room with his glasses off and his hands folded on the table, the whole length, without moving, and when it ended he sat for a minute in silence.

"I'm sorry," he said, finally.

"I wanted you to hear it."

"I'm glad you did." He looked up. His eyes were red. "I'll send it to a forensic lab in Columbus. They can clean the audio. They can't give us a name, but they can give us an age range, a vocal profile. A way to exclude." He stopped, and began again. "It was a homicide, Ms. Kowalczyk. I don't say that lightly. I've held the original coroner's report. It was never a fall."

"I know."

"I'd like to reopen it formally. With the county. I'd need your consent as next of kin."

"You have it."

"Thank you." He rubbed his eyes. "And I'd like to say, for what it's worth, that your father was the bravest man I've never met."

I couldn't answer. I only nodded.

On Thursday, the league board met in Pittsburgh, and by evening Okafor's phone buzzed with a message that made him smile for the first time since I'd known him.

The board had voted, five to two, to place the Kestrels' ice plant under independent supervision for the remainder of the investigation. A neutral monitor, approved by the integrity office, would sit in the engine room for every home game. No remote access. No Polar Peak. No shadow loops. The monitor had one name on the order, signed in the margin in Okafor's careful block capitals.

Hollis Pike arrived Friday afternoon in the mud-spattered pickup, with a rod rack on the roof and forty-two feet of binders in the bed.

"Move over," he said to Rory Sprague, who had been standing at the control cabinet in a navy polo with the expression of a man who has just been informed his house is in a different time zone. "I've got orders."

"I don't think..."

"I don't care what you think, son. I care what the paper says." Hollis waved a sheet under his nose. "It says I sit here. It says you go home."

Rory looked at me. I was standing at the foot of the stairs with my arms crossed and a smile I wasn't even trying to hide.

He picked up his laptop. He walked past me and up the stairs without a word, and I heard the door close, and for the first time in a month I walked into the engine room as the person in charge of it.

I put my hand flat on Old Mabel's flank. She hummed under my palm like a cat.

"Hello, old girl," I said. "I'm back."

We played the Saltmarsh Gulls that Saturday, November 22, and I ran the ice myself.

Twenty-three point nine at puck drop. Brine at sixteen point seven. A clean, fast, ordinary sheet. No ghost. No soup. No glass. Hollis sat on a stool by the control PC with a thermos and a legal pad, calling the numbers aloud in a bored, comfortable voice like a man reading the weather in a small town.

"Twenty-three nine. Twenty-three nine. Twenty-three nine. Gets boring, doesn't it?"

"It's the best thing in the world," I said.

Upstairs, the building shook.

I stood in the engine room, listening to it through the ceiling, a sound like a landslide. A goal. Then a long, rising wave of noise, a chant, a roar. I didn't have to see. I could feel it in my teeth.

Kestrels 3, Gulls 0.

Cal Dorsey stopped twenty-nine shots. It was the first shutout of his comeback, and when he skated off the ice at the end of the game, with his mask in his hand and sweat running down his face, three thousand people stood up and shouted his name for six straight minutes. They didn't stop when he went into the tunnel. They didn't stop when the lights came up. Somebody started a chant. Somebody else took it up. The whole Kettle was chanting a single word, and I realized, halfway through, what it was.

"CLEAN! CLEAN! CLEAN!"

I laughed. I put my forehead down on the cold steel of the cabinet and laughed until my ribs hurt.

On Monday morning, Okafor called me from the airport.

"I have news," he said. "Two things. The league has set a date for Mr. Dorsey's hearing. They've agreed to review his ban in light of the new evidence."

"When?"

"December fourteenth. A Sunday. At the league office in Pittsburgh."

"The day before the vote."

"The day before the vote." I heard him smile. "Somebody has a sense of theater."

"What's the second thing?"

"The audio lab called an hour ago." His voice dropped. "They cleaned the recording. They've isolated the second voice. It's a short phrase, four words, but they can say one thing about it for certain."

"What?"

"The speaker was whispering," said Okafor, "on purpose, to hide their voice."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!