Skip to content
Zodygo
Clean Ice

Chapter 23

Thirty-One Unsent

Cal came to my kitchen door on Monday night carrying a shoebox, and he looked like a man delivering a verdict to himself.

"Don't open it yet," he said.

"You're holding it like a bomb."

"It's worse. It's paper." He set it on the table between the salt shaker and a bowl of clementines, and took a step back, hands raised, as if the lid might come off on its own. "I've been working up to this for three weeks. I kept thinking, I'll give it to her after the Mercy Lake game. After Pete's wrist. After the fire. There's always a reason. Tonight I ran out."

It had been six days since the Kettle burned. The deputy's cruiser was still parked at the curb. We'd won on Saturday against the Saltmarsh Gulls, 4-2, on a sheet that Polar Peak kept honest only because Okafor stood in the tunnel the whole night with a thermometer and a notebook and the kind of stare you could cut glass with. The mood in the building had changed. People were speaking louder. Wyatt had scored twice.

"Sit," I said.

He sat. I put a mug of tea in front of him and slid into the chair across the table. The shoebox was battered cardboard, a Cold Harbor sporting goods store's name worn almost off the lid. Under the kitchen light it looked like a small, tired animal.

"It's letters," Cal said.

"To whom?"

"You."

My hand stopped on the clementine.

"Thirty-one of them. I counted last night." He cleared his throat. "I wrote one on every one of your birthdays since I left. That's ten. And I wrote some on the other days. The bad ones. After a loss. After my mother's funeral. After Game Five." He looked at the table. "I never sent them. I didn't have an address, and I didn't think I had the right. I just kept writing, and keeping them. I'm sorry. It's a weird thing to hand someone."

"It's not weird."

"It's a little weird."

"It's a lot weird." I laid my hand on the lid. "Why are you giving them to me now?"

"Because I'm tired of being the guy who doesn't say things." He met my eyes. "And because your father asked me to look at the ice, and I did, and I found out something that changes what I think I know. I don't want to go on holding the old version without telling you."

I lifted the lid.

They were all in envelopes, white and cream and one yellow, stacked on their sides like files. Each had a date penciled in the corner. Some had grown soft and gray from carrying. The first one in the front was dated September 19, ten years ago.

My name was on the front, in his blocky left-slanting capitals. MAR.

I took it out. My fingers were not quite steady, and I made myself breathe.

Mar,

It's four in the morning and I'm in an apartment in Cold Harbor with nothing on the walls and a refrigerator full of other people's food. The team gave us a welcome basket. I ate the cheese before I figured out it was somebody else's. Everyone here is very big and very sure.

I wanted to tell you about my first practice. The goalie coach said I had good hands and bad feet and I said I'd work on the feet. He said where did you learn to skate backward like that and I said a woman named Marnie taught me with her eyes closed. He laughed. He didn't understand.

I'm not going to mail this. You told me you were going to Chicago. I understand that. I wanted you to have the thing you wanted. But I wanted to say I miss the sound of the flood, and I miss you, and I'm sorry I said so little.

Cal

I looked up.

"I told you I was going to Chicago," I said.

Cal had gone very still.

"That's what it says. 'You told me you were going to Chicago.'" I put the letter on the table. My voice sounded odd to me, high and thin, like a note played on a cracked glass. "Cal, I never told you that."

"What?"

"I never told you that. I didn't go to Chicago until the next year. Ten months after you left." I stared at him. "I didn't have the job when you left. I wasn't applying. I hadn't even been to Chicago. I got the interview in January, through a man my father knew at a trade show. I was going to ask you what you thought. I called you in February and you didn't pick up."

"I was on a road trip. I called back in March."

"I didn't pick up either. I was scared." I swallowed. "We were both scared."

He'd gone the color of paper.

"Mar." He pressed his hands flat against the table. "That night in the parking lot. The night before I left. Your father walked me to my car. You remember. It was raining. You were inside, upstairs, packing up the plant log. He put his hand on my shoulder. He said, Cal, I want you to take this chance."

"I remember the rain."

"He said, Marnie's been offered a job in Chicago. A big one. She's taking it. She hasn't told you because she doesn't want to be the reason you don't go. She loves you. She'll never say it. If you ask her to stay, she will, and she'll hate the rink for the rest of her life."

I couldn't breathe.

"He told me to say nothing," Cal said. "He said, let her go. And I thought, he knows her better than I do. He's her father. I thought if I asked, I'd be making her choose." His voice cracked, and he cleared it. "So I didn't ask. I got in the car. I drove to the airport, and I wrote this in the terminal, and I never sent it."

"He lied."

"What?"

"He lied to you." My own voice came out strangely quiet. "He told you a thing that wasn't true, to make you leave. And he lied to me, because he told me you'd left without a word."

"I did leave without a word."

"He said you'd taken the CHA contract two weeks early because you didn't want to say goodbye." I could hear my own heart. "He said you were ashamed. He said you didn't think I was good enough."

"Mar, I never..."

"I know. I know you didn't." I put my hand over my mouth. For a second I thought I was going to be sick, and then I thought I was going to laugh, and in the end I did neither. I just sat there, with ten years going round in my head like water through a pipe, and a shoebox full of letters in front of me, and the awful perfect click of a thing falling into place.

"He lied to both of us," I said.

"Why?"

"I don't know." I wiped my face with the back of my hand. "I really don't know. I think he thought he was protecting me. Or the rink. Or you." A small, fierce laugh broke from me. "He wasn't good at it. He was so bad at lying that he did it by omission for ten years and never noticed it was a lie."

"I should have asked."

"I should have called."

"I should have asked," Cal repeated, and he reached across the table and took both my hands, and held them tight, and I let him. His hands were shaking too. We sat like that for a long time. The kitchen clock ticked.

"Ten years," I said.

"Ten years."

"He wasn't wrong about one thing. I would have stayed."

"I know."

"I'd have stayed in a heartbeat. I'd have hated it, probably. And I'd have loved you, and we'd both be forty and sick of each other." The laugh came again, wet and ragged. "That's a better outcome than what happened."

"Mar."

"I'm not saying it's okay." I squeezed his hands. "I'm saying I'm so angry at him I could scream. And I'm so grateful it's finally out in the open that I could scream the other way. Is that allowed?"

"It's the only thing that's ever been allowed."

"Okay."

I took the last envelope out of the box, the newest, still crisp, dated the week after Game Five. I only read one paragraph. I read it aloud, quietly, to the clementines.

"I'm in a hotel room and they took my skates for evidence. I didn't throw it, Mar. I didn't. I keep wanting to tell someone who would know what it felt like, and the only person I can think of is a woman I haven't spoken to in nine years. I would give anything to hear a flood."

I put the letter down very gently on the table.

"I'd have picked up," I said. "If you'd called. Even then."

"I know that now."

"There's one more thing in the box," he said.

"Oh God."

"It's not a letter. It's a note. It came with my paychecks my first season." He pulled the lid off the bottom and lifted a folded card, thin, white, soft at the creases. "I didn't know whether to give it to you. I only found out tonight what it means."

I opened it.

It was a small index card, the kind my father used for everything. The handwriting was a hard pencil scrawl, slanted, firm.

Cal, Good start. Keep going. Don't write her, it will only make it harder. She is happy. Stay away until you've made your name. She'll wait only if she doesn't know. G.K.

I read it twice. Then I put my finger, carefully, on a tiny mark beside the second line, beside the words She is happy. It was almost nothing. A pencil dot, small as a grain of rice, pressed hard enough to dent the card.

"What is that?" Cal asked.

"It's his mark." My voice broke on the word. "I saw it in the notebook. All the way through. He put it next to a thing he knew was wrong. A little dot, in pencil, where he knew he was lying."

"He put a dot beside a lie."

"He couldn't help it." I laughed and cried at once. "He couldn't write a lie without marking it. Like a man leaving a door open in case somebody wanted to find him."

Cal took the card back, gently, and looked at the dot, and I saw the thing happen to his face that had happened to mine, a slow, helpless crumpling. He put his forehead down on the table, on top of his folded arms.

I got up. I went around the table. I stood behind him with my hands on his back, and I let them stay there.

"What else did he lie about?" I whispered.

Cal didn't answer. He couldn't. And I realized I wasn't asking him.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!