Watching your own ice betray the man you love, from a seat in the stands, is a special kind of hell.
I'd bought a ticket. That was Okafor's idea. "Employees have access," he'd said, on Friday, over the phone. "Owners have a very public reason to be present. Fans are invisible." So on Saturday night I sat in Section 112, row F, seat 4, between a man in a Kestrels sweatshirt eating a pretzel and Daniel Okafor, who had put on a plain gray fleece and a baseball cap and looked, I'll say, exactly like a retired detective trying not to look like one.
"Do not do anything," he'd told me at the gate.
"I won't."
"Do not go downstairs. Do not touch a door. Do not text the boy in the engine room."
"Gus texts me."
"Then don't answer."
He had a small black thermometer clipped to his belt. An infrared one, for the surface of the ice, from a hardware store in Dayton. He'd explained to me that it wasn't a perfect instrument, but it was dated, calibrated, and photographed, and he planned to hold it up in the third row of a minor-league hockey game and take readings on the sly, like a man checking his phone.
"You think they'll do it?" I'd asked.
"I think they have it on the schedule." His voice had been very dry. "A man who writes his own complaint is a man who plans to be proved right."
Now it was 7:06. The Mercy Lake Loons had won the opening faceoff. Cal was in the Kestrels' net, a lonely figure in white and rust, bouncing on his skates the way he does before a puck drops, and the crowd was giving him a standing ovation. A real one. Three thousand people on their feet. In Section 118 a woman held up a glitter sign. DORSEY IS INNOCENT. She'd added a second line since the opener, in smaller letters: WE ALL SAW THE ICE.
I could have wept.
"Slab?" Okafor murmured.
"Twenty-three nine." I'd been reading it since I walked in, by the sound of the first skaters' warm-up laps. "Good. It's a good sheet."
"Whose?"
"Mine. I built it." I swallowed. "On Thursday. Before they took the machine."
The Zamboni had been Polar Peak's since Friday. A big white truck with a snowflake logo had parked at the loading dock and unloaded a brand-new machine, gleaming and quiet and electric, like something from a catalog. Big Ruth sat in the garage under a tarp. Gus had been told he could keep his job if he kept his head down.
7:15. 7:20. The first period ground on, even, honest, a hockey game on an honest sheet. Tank scored at 11:40. Mercy Lake tied it at 15:02. The sound of the blades was clean and high and true. I let myself breathe.
Then at 7:36 my phone buzzed.
Gus: armed
At 7:38 it buzzed again.
Gus: running. RECIPE_FNL_4. BIAS -2.4 ramp 60
I turned the phone face down on my knee. My hands were cold.
"Mr. Okafor."
"I see it," he said, without moving his lips.
He held up his phone, as if checking a score, and I watched him pass his thermometer over the glass. His face didn't change. "Twenty-three point four," he said. "Twenty-two point nine."
"It's going colder."
"How much?"
"Two and a half. Three. It'll scream." I tried to keep my voice even. "A cold sheet's faster. Harder. The puck skips, the stick bites. It makes everything bounce wrong. It turns a shot you could read into a shot you can't."
"And the goalie?"
"The goalie's the one who pays."
On the ice, a Mercy Lake forward collected the puck behind the Kestrels' net and wrapped it around the boards. I'd have said it was a harmless play. The puck came off the stick like a spark, flew the whole width of the crease on a flat bounce, hit the end boards and rebounded hard into the slot, where a second winger, standing alone, tapped it in.
2-1. Mercy Lake.
At 7:44 they scored again, off a shot that skipped twice on its way to the goal. At 7:51 again, a deflection that rose and hit Cal's shoulder and dropped, a lazy, ugly thing, over the line.
4-1.
The crowd, which had been standing, began to sit.
"Do something," said the man in the Kestrels sweatshirt, to nobody, with his pretzel halfway to his mouth. "What's wrong with them? Something's wrong with the ice."
"Everything's fine," I heard myself say.
"Lady, it's not fine."
"It's hockey."
I looked at the ice. I could see it with my eyes closed, the faint sheen on the surface where a degree of frost was beginning to form, the way a window fogs in a cold room. Every Kestrels defender was skating slightly too fast, overcorrecting, just a hair, like drivers on black ice. Cal was dropping into his butterfly a quarter-second early. He couldn't read it. The whole building had gone out of true.
"That's it," Okafor said very softly. "That's the whole trick."
"It's a cruelty," I whispered.
"It's a crime."
"It's both."
My phone buzzed against my leg.
Gus: I can pull the breaker. Say the word.
I looked at Okafor. He hadn't turned his head, but I knew he'd seen.
"No," he said.
"If I tell him to throw the main..."
"They'll say you did it. Whatever happens here tonight, I need one clean night of the thing running exactly as designed. I need the log, the temperatures, the timing, and I need the men who hit the button to be the ones in the room." His mouth thinned. "If you throw the switch, you're the saboteur. I don't want that for you."
"They're destroying him."
"I know."
"They're doing it again. Right in front of me."
"I know," Okafor said quietly. "And it is the best evidence I will ever have."
I closed my eyes. In my head I could hear every note of that ice, the glass, the hiss, the hateful clean whine. I thought of Cal with a towel over his head in a visitors' hallway. I thought of the words in my father's handwriting.
Gus, I typed. Don't.
I put the phone away. I put my hands on my knees. I sat there like a stone and watched the first period end 4-1, and the second period begin, and Cal go down on one knee as a puck skipped off a post and in.
5-1.
"BOOOOO."
The sound was low at first, a mutter. Then it grew, spreading through the building like water through ice. Someone shouted, "FIX-ED!" Another voice took it up. And then the Kettle, my beloved ugly, loyal Kettle, that had stood for this man two weeks before, began to chant.
"FIX-ED! FIX-ED! FIX-ED!"
Then, from Section 106, one voice rose above the rest, small and cracked and fearless, a voice that had sold tickets at the Kettle's window for thirty-one years.
"You hush!"
It was Babcia. She was on her feet in the front row with her purse over one arm and her cane raised like a sword, and eleven church ladies stood up behind her in a row. "You hush, all of you! That boy is a Port Ansel boy! You boo him, you boo your own sons!"
The chant faltered. It did not stop. But a few voices dropped out, ashamed, and the ones that stayed sounded smaller.
I stood up.
"Sit down," Okafor said.
"They're booing him."
"They're booing the score."
"They're booing him." My voice cracked. "They don't know. They don't know it's the ice. They think he's doing it again."
"Marnie." His large hand closed around my wrist, firm and gentle. "Sit. I need you here."
I looked down at the rink. Cal had come out of the crease. He stood on the goal line, mask in his hand, staring up at the stands, at the three thousand people whose names he'd once known. He was looking for something. A face. A sign.
He found my section. He looked right at me, across eighty feet of cold air. I couldn't see his expression. But I saw his hand move, slow, tired, as if he'd been about to wave and had thought better of it. He put it on top of his head instead and held it there.
Dee yanked him at 8:12, with the score 6-1, in the middle of the second period. A long, terrible walk to the bench.
Lutz went in. Lutz gave up the seventh.
Final: 7-2, Mercy Lake. The horn sounded to a half-empty building. The boos continued, softer, tired, a kind of weather. A woman in Section 118 sat with her sign in her lap, and nobody in the house was looking at her.
He tilted the little black thermometer toward me so I could see the last reading, a cold red number glowing on its screen: 21.6. Three degrees under the setpoint on the wall, and my sheet had been 23.9 at puck drop. Four lines on a legal pad, dated and timed in a cop's square handwriting, and not one of them could be argued with.
"I'll get the log copy tonight," Okafor said. His voice was rough. "I'll have it by midnight. Then I'll go to the league. This is a fixed game, Ms. Kowalczyk. I can prove it."
"Not a person."
"Not yet."
"But the ice."
"The ice I can prove." He let go of my wrist. "I'm sorry. I know what it cost."
I stood in the stands, and the lights went up, and people began shuffling out. A few of them looked at me as they went, because I'm the owner, because I'm Gene's daughter. A man I'd never met said, quietly, "Shame about the goalie." Another said, "Told you." A teenager said, "That guy's a fraud."
My phone buzzed again.
Nadia: Come to the tunnel. NOW. Wyatt is gone.
I ran.
The corridor behind the Kestrels' bench was crowded with players in half-removed pads and coaches in shirtsleeves and a loud, strained quiet. Dee stood in the center with her knitting bag on her shoulder and her face a gray stone. Tank was beside her, one glove off, breathing hard.
"Where is he?" I said.
"He didn't come out after the second," Tank said. "Intermission, he said he needed the bathroom. He went in. Nobody's seen him."
"His phone?"
"In his locker. His skates. His jersey. All of it. On the floor." Tank's voice was tight. "His wallet's gone. And his coat. He walked out of this building in the middle of a game and he didn't tell a soul."
Cal appeared at the end of the corridor. He was still in his pads, mask hanging from his hand, hair soaked. He looked at me, at Dee, at Tank, at the empty space where a loud kid should have been.
"Where's Wyatt?" he said.
Nobody answered.
Because nobody knew.

