Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 22

Coffee with Mr. Vale

Draft term sheet, titled "The Compact of Keeping," eleven pages, handed across a table with a bakery box and a pair of reading glasses. My note on page one, in black ink, written before I'd finished the first paragraph: Someone read the Mutual's bylaws before writing this. Not carefully enough.

Orrin Vale set the bakery box on the table and opened it. Cinnamon rolls, a dozen, still faintly warm.

"I'm not going to pretend they're not a gesture," he said. "I'm told it's rude to bring nothing."

"Don't eat anything," said Kasper, in a voice with no air in it.

"Nobody's going to eat anything, Kasper. I've known you four years. I know you wouldn't take a bite of a roll if I handed it to you on my knees." Vale sat down in the chair with the cushion, without being asked, and folded his hands. "I've brought them for her. Ms. Lindmark. Forgive me. I'm told you've had a hard morning."

"I'm not hungry."

"Then they'll keep."

I should say that I had expected something else. I'd expected a villain, a Strand with a different coat. Orrin Vale looked like a retired high-school principal who had once been a competent engineer. His hands were folded. His eyes were gray and attentive. When he looked at Teo, who stood by the stove with his fists closed, there was no triumph in the look. There was something very like regret.

"Captain Aasland," said Vale. "I'd have liked to meet you in another way."

"You Named my brother."

"I did. I saved his life, and I Named him. I've never denied either." His voice was gentle. "I understand you'd like to hit me. I would prefer that you didn't. Not because I'd mind. Because Kasper would feel it, and I'd rather he didn't."

Teo's hands opened by a fraction.

"Mr. Vale," I said. "What is this?"

I had picked up the first page without noticing. It was a good document, with numbered paragraphs, defined terms, and a recital that began WHEREAS. It was typed on heavy cream paper, and the paper made my stomach turn, because I knew the weight of it. I'd held it in a bathroom in the middle of the night.

"It's a proposal," said Vale. "I'd call it an insurance product, though it's more than that. It's a compact between a Keeper and a community. Eleven pages. The Keeper provides secure kennels, built to a standard you have never seen, in a facility already prepared. The Keeper pays every loss, in full, from a fund that does not run dry. The Pass gives up one thing."

"The vote," said Teo.

"The vote, and the Book, and the Clerk. They'd be administered by the Keeper." He spread his hands. "Look at what you've got. A tarp roof. A freezer. A pencil ledger. A woman with a rolling pin and a hundred and ten folding chairs. It's lovely, Captain, and it's killing you. You are one latch from a funeral every month."

"We've never had a funeral."

"You've had Kasper."

Teo took a step forward. Kasper said, "Teo, don't," hoarsely, and Teo stopped.

"I'm not your enemy," said Vale. "I'm the only person in forty years who has offered you anything. The Strands want the land. I want the people."

"That's worse," I said.

"Is it?" He turned to me with polite interest. "Ms. Lindmark. You're the adjuster. You tell me. A man who wants your house and a man who wants to keep you in it. Which one would you rather insure?"

"The one who doesn't have a collar on Teo's brother."

"Fair." He smiled. "I'm only a person with a different idea of what keeping means." He nodded at the term sheet. "Read it. Please. I'd rather you read it than not. People who read it say yes, in the end. They always say yes. It's very well drafted."

"Thank you," I said. "I'm going to."

I read it standing, in the corner by the iron stove, with a black pen. It took eleven minutes. The room was silent. Vale watched me with the faint interest of a man who has set a puzzle for a child and is curious how she will solve it.

It was a good document. I'll say it. Whoever had drafted it knew his law. The terms were clear and generous. The costs were hidden where costs hide, in the definitions, in a paragraph called Survival, in the line under Release that began The Keeper may, at his sole discretion. Section 14.2 stated that the obligations of any Named party survived the dissolution of the Compact. A Named member did not simply answer to the Keeper. He answered to a successor, and to his successor's heirs.

It was a lifetime lien on a human being, written in the language of a commercial property form.

I turned to the signature page. It said that the Compact took effect "upon execution by a duly authorized representative of the Community, acting pursuant to the Community's rules of governance."

I read it again.

"Mr. Vale," I said. "Who's the Community's duly authorized representative?"

"Whoever your bylaws name. I used the Chair."

"The Chair of the Pell Pass Mutual is Teodor Aasland, as of November seventh. He's right there." I pointed with the pen. "The bylaws, Article 6, provide that the Chair has no authority to bind the Mutual to any contract of more than one year, or any contract affecting the 'rights of membership,' without a vote of two thirds of the full membership, not those present. The full membership is two hundred and eleven. Two thirds is one hundred and forty-one. We've never gotten a hundred and forty-one people into the Grange in seventy-three years, except once, for a funeral, and that was an assembly, not a vote."

Vale's face did not change.

"And Article 11," I went on, "provides that no member may waive the vote by individual consent. A member who signs a side agreement with an outside party, without a ballot, is deemed to have resigned. Which means that your Compact, as drafted, can only take effect by a vote you'd lose, and that the only other way is a series of private signatures, which would remove each signer from the Mutual and leave you contracting with a collection of strangers, on an unincorporated basis, with no authorized representative, and no Community at all."

"Hm," said Vale.

"There's more." I flipped the page. "Your Release clause. 'The Keeper may release a Named party upon proof of a debt discharged.' You do not define 'debt.' You don't say what's owed. In the language of an adjuster, Mr. Vale, that's an ambiguous term, and ambiguity is construed against the drafter." "You wrote a lien with no price on it, which means any court that ever sees it will say the price is zero. Kasper has already paid. He's paid four years. He's paid a window and a hut and a stamp. By your own terms, he's discharged."

There was a long silence.

Then Orrin Vale began, slowly, to laugh.

It was a soft, delighted sound. "Oh, that's very good," he said. "That's exceptional. I was told you were good. I was told you'd found the late notice. I'd no idea you'd go through the Release." He took off his reading glasses, wiped them on his coat, and put them back on. "I drafted this myself, Ms. Lindmark. I've written eleven of them. In forty years, no one has ever read paragraph nine."

"Then you've never met an adjuster."

"I've never met one I liked." He smiled. "I think I do."

"Does that mean you release him?"

"It means I accept that there is a dispute about the meaning of a clause." He folded his hands. "It does not mean the Naming stops. A Naming is not a contract. It's a fact. You can win every argument on paper, Ms. Lindmark, and Kasper will still come when I call. That part isn't written down anywhere you can reach."

I did not say anything.

"But I'm a reasonable man," said Vale. "And I don't like to do business with a person who has beaten me by a clause. So I'll offer a truce." He rose, and Teo's hand went to Kasper's arm. "Until Sunday the seventh. No calling, no stamps, no damage. I'll even leave Mr. Strand to his lawyers."

"Why?" said Teo.

"Because the Three begins in six days." Vale picked up his thermos. "And on the first night, Captain, when your locked doors are locked, and your people are in your freezer, and your barn has a tarp, I am going to call your brother to the Lodge. I would rather not. But I want you to understand what a lock is worth, before you vote."

He walked to the door. At the threshold, he turned.

"The rolls are for you, Ms. Lindmark. They really are very good."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!