File note, on an unlined index card: 1. Mallet head, carved paw, larch. 2. Grain runs against the cut. 3. Whoever made this was paid twice, once for the wood and once for the quiet.
I did not open the margin note until the following morning, and I am not proud of that. I sat on Mick's chaise with the mill envelope in my lap and the radiator knocking, and I let myself have one night of not knowing. Procedure calls it a cooling-off period. My mother would have called it cowardice with a calendar.
Brice Quillan knocked at seven-thirty. He had a thermos and a printout.
"Still-frames from the Grange," he said. "I had a friend with a better monitor enhance the mallet. I want to know who carved it."
"A paw with the pads cut shallow on one side," I said. I had memorized the photograph. "Whoever made it was left-handed, or sat at the wrong end of the bench."
"Left-handed," said Brice. "And the grain is larch, not pine. Larch is expensive and nobody uses it for rubber stamps. It's what you use for something that has to take hitting."
"Teo says the old mill burned in 1999. They kept the larch beams. The Pass sold them for firewood and salvage."
"Then we want a man who bought mill larch from somebody's woodpile." He handed me the thermos lid, full of coffee. "I called every craft supplier and hobby woodcarver in three counties on the Mutual's dime, before breakfast. One of them stopped talking when I said 'paw.'"
His name was Anselm Pruitt, and he lived forty minutes down the valley in a town called Dunmore, over a shop that sold birdhouses, chessmen and walking sticks. We drove in Brice's gray sedan. He drove with both hands on the wheel at ten and two and said the speed limit out loud at each sign. I enjoyed it more than I expected.
"You're on leave," he said, at the Dunmore sign. "I'm a contractor. Between us we have no authority at all."
"Then we'll have to be friendly."
"I'm very good at friendly. People say so." He considered. "Teo says I'm like a bailiff who has gone to a spa."
Anselm Pruitt was seventy-one and had hands the size of dinner plates. He was sanding a chess knight when we came in, and he did not look up for the length of one full stroke. Behind him, along the wall, ran a rack of carved things: owls, boots, a trout, a row of little hands with the fingers curled.
"Closed," he said. "I'm closed until Thursday."
"It's Friday," I said.
"Then I'm closed until Thursday next." He blew dust off the knight. "I don't do tourists."
"We're not tourists, Mr. Pruitt. I'm Jo Lindmark. This is Brice Quillan." I put the printout on the bench, face up, and tapped the paw with a black pen. "Somebody paid you for this. They used it to break a window in Pell Pass and I'd like you to hear that from someone who isn't a sheriff."
He stopped sanding. The shop was very quiet, except for a radio somewhere in the back playing a ballgame at low volume.
"I didn't break nothing," he said.
"I know," said Brice. "I can see you carve right-handed from your callus, which means your man was the left-handed one. I'm only here to ask who ordered it."
Anselm Pruitt turned the knight in his hands. Then he laughed, a short ugly laugh through his nose, and put down the sandpaper.
"It's the damnedest thing. Everybody's nervous about the money and nobody's nervous about the tool. Sit. Not there, that's my wife's chair."
I sat. Brice stood. The old man took a ledger from a drawer, a green cloth-bound thing, and put it on the bench between us.
"Three years back, a fellow phones. Polite. Says he wants a rubber-stamp pad made out of wood, a dog's paw, certain size, certain spread. Four-toed, he says, not five, and the middle two a little ahead of the outer ones. I said that sounds like a wolf. He said it sounds like a dog. I said yes sir."
"And the larch?"
"He sent it himself. A box of old beam ends, charred on one face. I knew what it was before I opened it. Mill larch. You can't burn that stuff all the way through." He turned the pages, found the line, and set a finger under it. "Cash up front, in an envelope, no name. Then every few months he'd want another. Smaller. Different stride. Six in all."
"Three years," I said. I did the arithmetic out loud, because I was upset. "That's longer than any of the claims we've flagged. The first staged damage on the Mutual's books is two years old."
"Then he started practicing before he started," said Brice.
"He said he wasn't a handy man," said Anselm. "Paid for the sizing, said he didn't have the patience. He wanted them to look old. 'A paw wears down, he said.' Like he knew." He closed the ledger and kept his hand on it. "I thought about calling someone about that. And then I thought about my pension, which is small, and about how a fellow who sends a dog's paw to be carved in burned mill timber is either a lunatic or a man with a very specific grudge, and I figured that he'd get caught without my help."
"How did he pay?"
"A drop box at the Dunmore post office. The last one was in an envelope marked Pruitt Woodworks, Box 14, with a stamped return address, which I will tell you is fake because I wrote to it and it came back." He picked up a pencil and tapped it twice on the ledger. "But I'll tell you what he did not know, miss. He did not know about the glue."
"The glue," said Brice.
"Every piece I've ever carved for an order has a mark in the end grain. A tiny cut, like a maker's mark. Mine's an A and a P in a circle. A man who is paying me for quiet doesn't think about that. If you ever find the stamp itself, you'll see it."
I felt the click that I sometimes feel in a long file, right before the answer comes.
"Mr. Pruitt," I said, "the mallet in the Grange footage is in the sheriff's evidence locker? No. It's with the man who used it. If I ever got hold of it, would you identify your mark?"
"In a heartbeat. I'd like to see it come home. A man shouldn't put his name on a thing he's ashamed of." He tapped the pencil once more. "That's why I'm telling you. You're the first people who asked without giving me a lecture."
"You have good chairs," I said.
"My wife says it's the only reason I have friends."
He was reaching for the ledger when his face changed. He turned back a page, then another, and then put a thick finger on the last entry.
"There's one more. I didn't carve it yet. He phoned on Monday, and I wrote it down and forgot, because I'd been up at the hospital with my daughter." He read aloud, slowly, squinting. "Six more stamps. Not paws this time. Smaller. A set of boot-sole stamps, diamond lug, size twelve. Full pay in advance, done and left in the Pruitt box on Friday by closing."
I looked at the clock above the register. It was ten past eleven. The Friday he meant was today.
Brice had already taken out his phone.
"I'll tell you what I'm not going to say," he said, in a very mild voice. "I'm not going to say the word sting."
"I'd prefer you did," I said, and Mr. Pruitt stood up, and for the first time smiled at us, a wide dangerous smile like a man who has just been handed a good chisel.
"Then I'd better get started," he said. "I've got until closing."

