I started on the tenth pack the way I start on everything, with a records request and a bad attitude.
By midnight Cal Mercer had gone home with Pilar, my mother was asleep in the press box under two quilts, and my father had gone to find the thermos he claimed he had not lost. Ward and I sat on the first-base dugout bench with a laptop on my knees and the field lights off. The only light was the screen and the red dot of the security camera, which Ward had once told me was decorative.
“Stillwater,” I said. “Say it to me like a word, not a ghost.”
“It's a reservoir,” said Ward. “Upriver, forty minutes past Elk Mills. Dry Ridge Road. We went swimming there once, before I knew what it was.”
“What was it?”
“A town.” He rubbed his jaw. “I never asked. You don't ask what's under a lake.”
I asked. The state's dam inspection database is not a literary resource, but it is thorough. Stillwater Dam, earthen, completed in November 1962, creating a reservoir of nine hundred acres. Before that, the village of Stillwater: a grange hall, a church, a school, a mill, one main street, two hundred and eleven residents relocated by the state under a purchase order I could have recited from memory, because the form has not changed in sixty years. Fair market value, less a three percent administrative deduction.
“They took three percent off a town,” I said.
“Of course they did.”
“For the record, I find that more upsetting than the wolves.”
The Reservoir Authority's records gave me the rest. Its board of five, appointed by the governor. Its surplus land, one thousand two hundred acres of ridge above the waterline, held in trust and never sold. Its water levels, published weekly, and this year well below the spillway, because the summer had been dry. Last of all, its easement list, a dull page of utility corridors and boat ramps and one line I read three times.
Dry Ridge Grange Hall No. 41. Lease, nominal. Tenant: the Stillwater Grange Benevolent Association. Term: ninety-nine years, from 1962.
“A grange,” I said. “The farmers' lodge. They hold potlucks and vote on fair ribbons.”
“A pack could hide in that,” said Ward. “It's what we did with a baseball team.”
“Ward, you hid in a baseball team and I have been auditing it for six months. Don't tell me about hiding.”
He laughed, once, and it was a tired sound. Then he took the laptop from me and set it on the bench between us, as if it needed a place to sit.
“Cilla. We're going to find out Stillwater has a Caller. And she's been Calling sixty years and never paid.”
“Cal said it.”
“Cal could be wrong.”
“Cal is a man who keeps a list of fifty-one burned-out Callers and mails postcards to their families. If Cal says he cannot find a name on that list, then it isn't there.” I scrolled. “So the tenth pack's Caller has been doing sixteenths for sixty years. Which is one hundred and thirty or so Calls a year, if they run like us. Seven or eight thousand Calls. Five hundred sixteenths.”
“And?”
“And somebody is paying five hundred memories. That's not a ghost story, that's a liability. Liabilities have a ledger. Ledgers leave paper.”
“That's the most Auditor thing you've ever said.”
“It was a good week to say it.”
We worked another hour. I will not pretend it was romantic. At one point Ward fell asleep sitting up, and I covered his knees with a Herons jacket from the dugout hook, and then I sat very still because I had a number to find and was afraid that if I moved I would have to feel something about it.
Around two I stopped trusting the dam records and started distrusting the one document I had already closed. A good auditor reopens her own work first. It is the only way to find out how sloppy she was on a Tuesday.
The number was in the scholarship.
I had not meant to open it. My own file, the Aldersey Scholarship Fund, was a closed question, settled in October: the Tuckerman pack had paid for my degree, out of guilt, through a foundation that was a pack in all but filing. I had read the donor ledger once. I had read the Tuckermans, the Calloways, and the anonymous.
But Cal had said the word “tenth” and I did not trust my first reading of anything anymore. So I pulled the foundation's bank detail, the one-line deposit history, going back twenty years.
Most of it was what I expected. Bea's annual gift. Ward's, which began in his first year as GM and made me put the laptop down for a minute. Dale's small, embarrassed check every June. The fund had a front office, a lockbox, an old compliance officer named Mrs. Haas who answered my emails within the minute and signed them “Warmly.”
And there was a third donor, a name I had passed over in October because it was a name the way a number is a name. Grange 16.
I read the deposit history for Grange 16 three times.
Sixteen dollars. On the first of every month. Not a rounded sum, not a tax-shaped sum. Sixteen dollars, by cashier's check, from a credit union I had never heard of, Dry Ridge Federal, from August 2003 to this month.
Two hundred and eighty-six deposits.
“Ward,” I said.
He woke instantly, the way wolves apparently do, a hand already out. “What?”
“Who gave sixteen dollars a month to a scholarship for a girl they had never met?”
He took the screen from me. I watched him read it. He did the arithmetic faster than I did.
“Four thousand five hundred and seventy-six dollars,” he said. “In twenty years.”
“Twenty years and four months. It started in August 2003.” I put my finger on the first line. “Three weeks after the night my mother disappeared.”
Ward said nothing. A car went by on Riverside, and its lights crossed the infield and went out.
“Sixteen,” he said finally. “Like the sixteenth.”
“Like the rule. Or like a person who counts everything he gives.” I took the laptop back. My hands were steady, which I resented. “It isn't much. It would not have covered a semester. It's not meant to cover anything. It's meant to be paid.”
“Paid by who?”
“By someone who hasn't missed a month in two hundred and eighty-six, which is more than I can say for the Herons' concession tax.” I pulled up the cashier's check image, the most recent one, from the first of December. Dry Ridge Federal, a teller's stamp, the memo line in print. And in the corner, because the credit union's scanner is as bad as the state's, the faint ghost of a pencil mark on the back of the check.
It was yellow.
I zoomed. I did not need to. I knew that waxy line. I had seen it in a bank branch, on a pencil stub, in a bag of evidence, on a note under a booth door.
“Ward,” I said, “the man who put my mother in the Long Night has been paying toward my tuition.”

