The records room of the state’s Capitol complex is in a basement, because paper is heavy and the state does not like to look at what it has promised to keep. I had been down there four hundred times. I had never once felt my own pulse in my teeth.
“You’re early,” said Renata.
She stood at the long table inside the secure cage in a charcoal suit with a lanyard on, and she looked tired in a way I had never seen: not worn but unpinned. The woman who ran Field Audit like a ship’s purser had lost the last of her armor in October, and what had come up under it was a person. I liked her better. It made me nervous.
“I’m on time,” I said. “You said nine.”
“It’s 8:40.”
“Then I’m twenty minutes ahead of schedule, which is the only kind of ahead I know.”
She gave me a small, grim smile, and nodded toward the box on the table. “Open it.”
It was a standard gray archive carton, with TC-1148 on the end in my handwriting. The seal was a strip of red tape across the lid, signed along the edge. I knew that signature. It was mine. It was good, too, better than I would have done, slightly slanted, with the hook on the P I put there when I was seventeen.
“I didn’t sign that.”
“I know,” said Renata. “It’s a perfect forgery. The clerk at the desk said the woman who signed was in a gray coat with her hair up. She said, quote, you looked tired.”
“I was at the Away.”
“Which is why I haven’t called the Inspector General.” She pushed her glasses up. “Cilla, open the box. I’ve been staring at it for three hours.”
I broke the tape.
Inside lay a ream of workpaper in its wrapper, a few pencils, and a folded sheet in a manila folder. I slid the folder out. It said, in a typed label with a high lowercase e, For the Auditor.
I took a breath. The folder contained one document: a photocopy of a letter, on state letterhead, dated twenty-two years ago.
Re: Tuckerman Baseball, LLC. Audit No. TC-0311. Notice of Closure.
I read it twice. It was one paragraph. It said the Department had completed its review of the above taxpayer’s sales and withholding records for the period January 1 through June 15, 2003, and had found no basis for assessment. The audit was closed effective July 12. It was signed at the bottom by a Department examiner whose name I did not know, Harold Strand, and countersigned with a line that I read three times.
Closure requested and agreed by taxpayer’s authorized agent: C. Mercer.
I put it down on the table.
“There was an earlier audit,” I said.
“There was an earlier audit,” said Renata. Her voice was very even. “Opened June 24, 2003. Closed July 12. Eighteen days. For a ballpark with a gross of about three million a year, that’s the length of an afternoon.”
“Orrin didn’t say a word. Nobody said a word. Ward didn’t say it. Bea didn’t say it. I walked into this place in September with a thirty-day clock and nobody mentioned that the Department had been in the building before.”
“Because the file isn’t in our system,” said Renata. “I checked. It isn’t in the index, it isn’t in the archive manifest, it isn’t on microfilm. It doesn’t exist. Or it didn’t. Someone pulled it from deep storage and put it in your box.”
“Harold Strand,” I said. “Who is he?”
“Was. He retired in 2004. He died in 2006. He trained me.” She said it flatly. “He taught me to close files when the paperwork was clean. He taught me that you don’t ask why a taxpayer is cooperating.”
“Renata.”
“He was a decent man. He’d have been a decent man if he’d been bought.” Her mouth went tight. “I’ve spent three days thinking about the sort of person who would hand me, a lifelong administrator, the kind of ghost that’s been in my own office for twenty years. I came up with one answer. Somebody wants us to know that this wasn’t Strommen alone.”
“It could be Strommen.”
“It could. But Strommen wouldn’t give you the paper that proves the Herons were audited, cleared and let go, the week the Caller disappeared. That doesn’t help him. It helps you.” She leaned forward. “Somebody wants you to have it.”
I picked up the letter again. The paper was thin and yellowed, a photocopy of a copy. At the bottom, under the printed signature block, was the agent’s line. The loops in the C and the M were far too large. It was a boy’s hand, a young man’s, the kind of cursive learned from a chart on a classroom wall and never revised.
I had seen those loops twice before: once on a card taken out of a bank vault, and once on a page of a scorebook this week, under my mother’s last mark.
“Cal Mercer,” I said, “signed for the pack.”
“A nineteen-year-old apprentice,” said Renata, “signed on behalf of an LLC with an annual gross of three million. That’s not an agent, Cilla. That’s a human shield.”
“Or a scapegoat. In case it went wrong.”
“It went wrong.” She was looking at the letter, not at me. “Somebody knew on June 24 that a state examiner would be in the ballpark for eighteen days. And on July 12, the morning after the night Mo disappeared, someone sat Cal Mercer down in front of a pen and had him close it.”
I was already running figures. June 24 to July 11. Seventeen days. A state examiner at the park for seventeen days, and on the eighteenth, the night of the full moon, Maureen Aldersey went out to the quarry road and did not come back.
“Where’s Harold Strand’s workpaper?” I said. “His notes. There has to be a working file.”
“There isn’t.”
“There’s always a working file.”
“Then he took it, or it was taken.” Renata reached into the folder and slid out a smaller sheet. “This was behind the letter. A routing slip. From the closing desk, July 12, 2003, 9:05 a.m. It says the request to close came in by courier at 7:40. By hand. From the taxpayer’s agent.”
I read the slip. It had a block at the bottom for the courier’s signature. It was not signed. In the space for the name of the sender’s address, someone had written in a young, looping hand a single line.
“Nine Sorrel Lane,” I said. “Elk Mills.”
“Do you know it?”
“It’s forty minutes from here.” I did not look up. “That’s where Cal Mercer lived.”
We stood in the secure cage, among the shelves of other people’s unfinished business, under a fluorescent tube that hummed a half-step flat. I put the letter, the slip and the folder into a plain envelope, and then I did a thing I had not done in fifteen years of working for the state: I put it in my own bag, and I did not log it.
“I didn’t see you take that,” said Renata.
“Thank you.”
“Don’t thank me. If this goes where I think it goes, I’ll want it back, and a lot more.” She straightened her lanyard. “Cilla. There’s a camera on the lobby entrance. I pulled the footage for October 20.”
“And?”
“I saw the woman in the gray coat. She’s about your height. She wore a wig, I think, and a surgical mask. I could not see her face. But when she left the building at 4:20, she stopped on the sidewalk and handed the carton to someone on the curb.”
“Who?”
“A man,” said Renata. “Tall. Long coat. Gloves.” She stopped. “He did something I couldn’t explain. He took out a pencil. And he held it up to the camera, and tipped it at the lens, like a hat.”

